LawCite Search | LawCite Markup Tool | Help | Feedback

Law
Cite


Cases Referring to this Case | Law Reform Reports Referring to this Case | Law Journal Articles Referring to this Case | Legislation Cited | Cases and Articles Cited

Help

Andrews v City of Philadelphia   flag  84

895 F2d 1469; 52 Empl Prac Dec P 39,635; 54 Fair Empl Prac Cas 184
United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit
United States
8th February, 1990

Cases Referring to this Case

Case Name †  Citation(s) Court Jurisdiction Date Full Text Citation Index
Aman v Cort Furniture Rental Corporation 85 F3d 1074 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 30 May 1996 WorldLII flag 29
Anna Jensen v Jack E Potter US 435 F3d 444 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 31 Jan 2006 WorldLII flag 2
Annis v County of Westchester 136 F3d 239 United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit United States 28 Jan 1998 WorldLII flag 13
Aybike Kortan, Plaintiff-Appellant, v California Youth Authority; Albert Atesalp; Ir Schulman; Manual Carbajal, Defendants-Appellees 217 F3d 1104 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 7 Jul 2000 WorldLII flag 16
Back v Hastings on Hudson Union Free School District J 365 F3d 107 United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit United States 7 Apr 2004 WorldLII flag 7
Baker v Monroe Township 50 F3d 1186 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 1 May 1995 WorldLII flag 20
Bator v Hawaii 39 F3d 1021 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 8 Nov 1994 WorldLII flag 13
Beck v City of Pittsburgh 89 F3d 966 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 22 Jul 1996 WorldLII flag 7
Bielevicz v Dubinon 915 F2d 845 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 28 Sep 1990 WorldLII flag 17
Blackhawk v Pennsylvania 381 F3d 202 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 20 Aug 2004 WorldLII flag 1
Blanche Road Corporation v Bensalem Township 57 F3d 253 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 21 Jun 1995 WorldLII flag 20
Bonenberger v Plymouth Township 132 F3d 20 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 17 Dec 1997 WorldLII flag 7
Bouton v BMW of North America, Inc 29 F3d 103 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 3 Aug 1994 WorldLII flag 23
Brasko v City of Caney Oj Cleland [1997] USCA10 1335 United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit United States 9 Dec 1997 WorldLII flag
Bray v Marriott Hotels 110 F3d 986 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 11 Apr 1997 WorldLII flag 7
Brennan v Norton 350 F3d 399 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 5 Dec 2003 WorldLII flag 9
Brown v Borough of Mahaffey Pennsylvania M P 35 F3d 846; 63 USLW 2225 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 30 Sep 1994 WorldLII flag 3
Burns v McGregor Elec Indus , Inc 955 F2d 559 United States Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit United States 30 Jan 1992 WorldLII flag 29
Burns v McGregor Elec Indus , Inc 989 F2d 959 United States Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit United States 29 Apr 1993 WorldLII flag 26
Canutillo Independent School District v Leija 101 F3d 393; 114 Ed Law Rep 439 United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit United States 27 Nov 1996 WorldLII flag 17
Caver v City of Trenton 420 F3d 243 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 26 Aug 2005 WorldLII flag 5
Charles S Jones, Appellant v School District of Philadelphia United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit 198 F3d 403 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 10 Dec 1999 WorldLII flag 8
Daniels v Essex Group, Inc 937 F2d 1264; 56 Empl Prac Dec P 40,896; 56 Fair Empl Prac Cas 833 United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit United States 24 Jul 1991 WorldLII flag 52
DeAngelis v El Paso Mun Police Officers Ass'n 51 F3d 591 United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit United States 10 May 1995 WorldLII flag 28
Dillon v M Frank [1992] USCA6 44 United States Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit United States 15 Jan 1992 WorldLII flag
Doe Doe v City of Belleville Illinois 119 F3d 563 United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit United States 17 Jul 1997 WorldLII flag 16
Drinkwater v Union Carbide Corporation Hv 904 F2d 853; 53 Empl Prac Dec P 40,002; 56 Fair Empl Prac Cas 483 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 6 Jun 1990 WorldLII flag 16
Durham Life Ins Co v Evans 166 F3d 139 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 15 Jan 1999 WorldLII flag 14
Ellison v Brady 924 F2d 872; 59 USLW 2455; 55 Empl Prac Dec P 40,520; 55 Fair Empl Prac Cas 111 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 5 Feb 1991 WorldLII flag 88
Faragher v City of Boca Raton 111 F3d 1530 United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit United States 28 Apr 1997 WorldLII flag 14
Faragher v City of Boca Raton 524 US 775; 141 L Ed 2d 662; 118 SCt 2275 United States Supreme Court United States 26 Jun 1998 WorldLII flag 386
Gares v Willingboro Township 90 F3d 720 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 23 Jul 1996 WorldLII flag 7
Gertrude W Abramson, Appellant v William Paterson College of New Jersey 260 F3d 265 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 3 Aug 2001 WorldLII flag 16
Harwick v Anderson McClain County Oklahoma [1998] USCA10 499 United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit United States 7 May 1998 WorldLII flag
Hirschfeld v New Mexico Corrections Department 916 F2d 572; 54 Empl Prac Dec P 40,308; 54 Fair Empl Prac Cas 268 United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit United States 12 Oct 1990 WorldLII flag 44
Jackson v Quanex Corporation 191 F3d 647 United States Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit United States 9 Sep 1999 WorldLII flag 33
Jacqueline Watson, Appellant/Cross-Appellee, v Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority ("Septa"), Appellee/Cross-Appellant 207 F3d 207 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 20 Mar 2000 WorldLII flag 14
Jenkins v Wood 81 F3d 988 United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit United States 16 Apr 1996 WorldLII flag 29
Johnson v Martin 195 F3d 1208 United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit United States 1 Nov 1999 WorldLII flag 13
Kachmar v SunGard Data Sys , Inc 109 F3d 173 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 26 Mar 1997 WorldLII flag 22
Keenan v City of Philadelphia 983 F2d 459 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 21 Jan 1993 WorldLII flag 20
King v Hillen 21 F3d 1572 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 13 Apr 1994 WorldLII flag 20
Knabe v Boury Corporation 114 F3d 407 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 29 May 1997 WorldLII flag 16
Kneipp v Tedder 95 F3d 1199 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 18 Sep 1996 WorldLII flag 40
Konstantopoulos v Westvaco Corporation 112 F3d 710 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 6 May 1997 WorldLII flag 10
Kunin v Sears Roebuck and Co 175 F3d 289 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 28 Apr 1999 WorldLII flag 2
Langley v Adams County 987 F2d 1473 United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit United States 3 Mar 1993 WorldLII flag 29
Lankford v City of Hobart 73 F3d 283 United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit United States 4 Jan 1996 WorldLII flag 6
Laverdure v County of Montgomery 324 F3d 123 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 2 Apr 2003 WorldLII flag 2
McKenna v Pacific Rail Service 32 F3d 820 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 27 Sep 1994 WorldLII flag 18
Mendoza v Borden, Inc 195 F3d 1238 United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit United States 16 Nov 1999 WorldLII flag 21
Morris v Oldham County Fiscal Court 201 F3d 784 United States Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit United States 3 Mar 2000 WorldLII flag 29
Ocheltree v Scollon Productions Incorporated 308 F3d 351 United States Court of Appeals, Fourth Circuit United States 10 Oct 2002 WorldLII flag 2
Patricia a Raniola, Plaintiff-Appellant, v Police Commissioner William Bratton; Police Commissioner Howard Safir; New York City Police Department; Rudolph Giuliani, Mayor; the City of New York; Anthony Kissik, Defendants-Appellees 243 F3d 610 United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit United States 19 Mar 2001 WorldLII flag 7
Patricia D Skidmore, Plaintiff-Appellee, v Precision Printing and Packaging, Incorporated; Anheuser Busch Companies, Inc; Jay Mitchell, Defendants-Appellants 188 F3d 606 United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit United States 13 Sep 1999 WorldLII flag 15
Pavlik v Lane Ltd/tobacco Exporters International 135 F3d 876 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 4 Feb 1998 WorldLII flag 1
Penry v Federal Home Loan Bank of Topeka R Gillum 155 F3d 1257 United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit United States 15 Sep 1998 WorldLII flag 13
Rebecca LEWIS, Brenda Heath, , Plaintiffs-Appellees, v David McDADE, individually and in his official capacity as District Attorney, Defendant-Appellant 250 F3d 1320 United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit United States 21 May 2001 WorldLII flag
Robinson v City of Pittsburgh 120 F3d 1286 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 14 Jul 1997 WorldLII flag 28
Roth v Koppers Industries Inc 993 F2d 1058 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 24 May 1993 WorldLII flag 6
Saulpaugh v Monroe Community Hosp 4 F3d 134 United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit United States 27 Aug 1993 WorldLII flag 43
Shuman v Penn Manor School District M D B 422 F3d 141 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 7 Sep 2005 WorldLII flag 4
Simmons v City of Philadelphia 947 F2d 1042; 21 Fed RServ3d 966 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 21 Nov 1991 WorldLII flag 42
Southard v Texas Board of Criminal Justice a 114 F3d 539 United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit United States 13 Jun 1997 WorldLII flag 16
Spain v Gallegos 26 F3d 439 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 16 Jun 1994 WorldLII flag 24
Stacks v Southwestern Bell Yellow Pages, Inc 27 F3d 1316 United States Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit United States 24 Jun 1994 WorldLII flag 26
Suders v D Easton D B 325 F3d 432 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 16 Apr 2003 WorldLII flag 9
Torres v McLaughlin 163 F3d 169 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 15 Dec 1998 WorldLII flag 14
Torres v Pisano 116 F3d 625 United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit United States 3 Jun 1997 WorldLII flag 40
Twisdale v W Snow 325 F3d 950 United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit United States 10 Apr 2003 WorldLII flag 3
Watson 478 F3d 144 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 16 Feb 2007 WorldLII flag 1
West v Philadelphia Elec Co 45 F3d 744 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 19 Jan 1995 WorldLII flag 23
Weston v Pennsylvania 251 F3d 420 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 22 May 2001 WorldLII flag 11
Williams v General Motors Corporation 187 F3d 553 United States Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit United States 30 Sep 1999 WorldLII flag 39
Williams v Neal W Zavaras [1996] USCA10 1375 United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit United States 18 Oct 1996 WorldLII flag
Winn v L Lynn 941 F2d 236 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 4 Sep 1991 WorldLII flag 2
Woodson v Scott Paper Co 109 F3d 913 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 6 May 1997 WorldLII flag 31
Woodward v City of Worland 977 F2d 1392 United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit United States 15 Dec 1992 WorldLII flag 49
Ymca of the Pikes Peak Region Inc v National Labor Relations Board 914 F2d 1442; 116 Lab Cas 10,357 United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit United States 26 Sep 1990 WorldLII flag 5
Younger v L Saffle [1998] USCA10 826 United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit United States 28 Jul 1998 WorldLII flag
Yuknis v First Student Inc 481 F3d 552 United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit United States 28 Mar 2007 WorldLII flag 1

Law Reform Reports Referring to this Case

Journal Article Title †  Citation(s) Author Jurisdiction Date Full Text Citation Index
- Review of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1977 (NSW) [1999] NSWLRC 92 New South Wales Law Reform Commission Australia - New South Wales circa 1999 AustLII flag

Law Journal Articles Referring to this Case

Journal Article Title †  Citation(s) Author Jurisdiction Date Full Text Citation Index
" Hostility to the Presence of Women " : Why Women Undermine Each Other in the Workplace and the Consequences for Title VII (2004) 113 Yale Law Journal 1579 Mizrahi, Ramit United States 1 Jan 2004 WorldLII flag
"Concepts of Reasonableness in Sexual Harassment Legislation: Did Queensland Get It Right" (2003) 3 Queensland University of Technology Law and Justice Journal 189 Pace, Fiona Australia - Queensland circa 2003 AustLII flag 1

Cases and Articles Cited

Case Name †  Citation(s) Court Jurisdiction Date Full Text Citation Index
"Sexual Harassment Claims of Abusive Work Environment Under Title VII" 97 Harvard Law Review 1449 Harvard Law Review United States HeinOnline / LexisNexis flag 12
Adickes v SH Kress & Co (1969) 398 US 144; 31 FRD 647; 26 L Ed 142; 26 L Ed 2d 142; 90 SCt 1598; [1970] Moore 754 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Jun 1970 WorldLII flag 1391
Anderson v Creighton 483 US 635; 97 L Ed 2d 523; 107 SCt 3034; 97 L Ed 523 United States Supreme Court United States 25 Jun 1987 WorldLII flag 2051
Anela v City of Wildwood Cole 790 F2d 1063 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 22 May 1986 WorldLII flag 9
Batson v Kentucky 476 US 79; 106 SCt 1712; 90 L Ed 2d 69; 90 L Ed 2d 79 United States Supreme Court United States 30 Apr 1986 WorldLII flag 1209
Bennett v Corroon & Black Corporation 845 F2d 104; 46 Empl Prac Dec P 37,955; 46 Fair Empl Prac Cas 1329 United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit United States 9 Jun 1988 WorldLII flag 13
Bohen v City of East Chicago Indiana 799 F2d 1180; 5 Fed RServ3d 1321; 55 USLW 2144; 41 Empl Prac Dec P 36,450; 41 Fair Empl Prac Cas 1108 United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit United States 28 Aug 1986 WorldLII flag 73
Bowersox v PH Glatfelter Co 677 FSupp 307 United States Westlaw flag 3
cert denied 481 US 1041; 107 SCt 1983; 95 L Ed 2d 823; 95 L Ed 822 United States Supreme Court United States Westlaw flag 128
cert denied 490 US 1020; 109 SCt 1745; 104 L Ed 2d 182 United States Supreme Court United States Westlaw flag 113
Chuy v Philadelphia Eagles Football Club 595 F2d 1265; 4 Media LRep 2537 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 9 Mar 1979 WorldLII flag 57
City of St Louis v Praprotnik 485 US 112; 99 L Ed 2d 107; 108 SCt 915 United States Supreme Court United States 2 Mar 1988 WorldLII flag 334
Civil Rights Act 1964 [1964] SEC 706; 42 USC 2000; 649 FSupp 647 United States circa 1964 flag 3468
Cox v Keystone Carbon Co 861 F2d 390 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 9 Nov 1988 WorldLII flag 15
Davis v Monsanto Chem Co 858 F2d 345 United States Westlaw flag 34
Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments and (1979) 42 USC 1983; 669 FSupp 625 United States Code United States circa 1983 LII (Cornell) flag 15693
Fireman's Fund Ins Co v Videfreeze Corporation 540 F2d 1171 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 25 Aug 1976 WorldLII flag 46
Ford v Isdaner 542 A2d 137; 374 Pa Super 40 United States circa 1976 flag 3
Griggs v Duke Power Co 401 US 424; 28 L Ed 2d 158; 91 SCt 849 United States Supreme Court United States 8 Mar 1971 WorldLII flag 968
Hall v Gus Constr Co 842 F2d 1010; 46 Empl Prac Dec P 37,905; 46 Fair Empl Prac Cas 573; 56 USLW 2571 United States Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit United States 25 Mar 1988 WorldLII flag 76
Harlow v Fitzgerald 457 US 800; 50 USLW 4815; 73 L Ed 2d 396; 102 SCt 2727; 818 Moore 57; 73 L Ed 396; [1982] Rice 999 United States Supreme Court United States 24 Jun 1982 WorldLII flag 3206
Hicks v Gates Rubber Co 833 F2d 1406; 266 USApp DC 190; 56 USLW 2328; 44 Empl Prac Dec P 37,542; 45 Fair Empl Prac Cas 608 United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit United States 25 Nov 1987 WorldLII flag 89
Jett v Dallas Indep Sch Dist 491 US 701; 105 L Ed 2d 598; 109 SCt 2702 United States Supreme Court United States 22 Jun 1989 WorldLII flag 209
Katz v Dole 709 F2d 251; 32 Empl Prac Dec P 33,639; 31 Fair Empl Prac Cas 1521 United States Court of Appeals, Fourth Circuit United States 1 Jun 1983 WorldLII flag 69
Kazatsky v King David Memorial Park, Inc 515 PA 183; 527 A2d 988 United States flag 8
Kuhar v Greensburg-Salem School District L 616 F2d 676; 22 Empl Prac Dec P 30,778; 22 Fair Empl Prac Cas 80 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 19 Feb 1980 WorldLII flag 4
Link v Mercedes-Benz of North America 788 F2d 918 United States Westlaw flag 58
Lipsett v University of Puerto Rico 864 F2d 881; 51 Ed Law Rep 35; 48 Empl Prac Dec P 38,393; 54 Fair Empl Prac Cas 230 United States Court of Appeals, First Circuit United States 26 Oct 1988 WorldLII flag 79
Lopez v Sb Thomas Inc 831 F2d 1184; 45 Empl Prac Dec P 37,613; 45 Fair Empl Prac Cas 140 United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit United States 22 Oct 1987 WorldLII flag 27
McKinney v Dole 765 F2d 1129; 246 USApp DC 376; 37 Empl Prac Dec P 35,339; 38 Fair Empl Prac Cas 364 United States Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit United States 2 Jul 1985 WorldLII flag 33
Meritor Savings Bank v Vinson 477 US 57; 91 L Ed 2d 49; 106 SCt 2399 United States Supreme Court United States 19 Jun 1986 WorldLII flag 633
Monell v Department of Social Services 436 US 658; 56 L Ed 2d 611; 98 SCt 2018; 692-94 Wright 21; 56 L Ed 611 United States Supreme Court United States 6 Jun 1978 WorldLII flag 2348
Pembaur v City of Cincinnati 475 US 469; 89 L Ed 2d 452; 106 SCt 1292; 89 L Ed 452 United States Supreme Court United States 25 Mar 1986 WorldLII flag 528
Rabidue v Osceola Refining Co 805 F2d 611; 42 Fair Empl Prac Cas 631 United States Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit United States 13 Nov 1986 WorldLII flag 79
Rich v United States Lines, Inc 596 F2d 541 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 6 Mar 1979 WorldLII flag 14
Rizzo v Goode 423 US 362; 44 USLW 4095; 46 L Ed 2d 561; 96 SCt 598 United States Supreme Court United States 21 Jan 1976 WorldLII flag 367
Rode v Dellarciprete 845 F2d 1195; 56 USLW 2625 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 28 Apr 1988 WorldLII flag 61
Roebuck v Drexel University 852 F2d 715; 48 Ed Law Rep 123; 11 Fed RServ3d 959; 47 Empl Prac Dec P 38,171; 47 Fair Empl Prac Cas 752 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 26 Jul 1988 WorldLII flag 36
Ryan v Burlington County New Jersey H Fauver 860 F2d 1199 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 2 Nov 1988 WorldLII flag 10
Sartor v Arkansas Natural Gas Corporation 321 US 620; 88 L Ed 967; 64 SCt 724; 90 SCt 1598; 88 L Ed 2d 967 United States Supreme Court United States 24 Apr 1944 WorldLII flag 1197
Steele v Offshore Shipbuilding Inc J McCullough 867 F2d 1311; 49 Empl Prac Dec P 38,839; 49 Fair Empl Prac Cas 522; 57 USLW 2541 United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit United States 19 Apr 1989 WorldLII flag 40
Thompson v Oklahoma 429 US 1053; 97 SCt 767; 50 L Ed 2d 770 United States Supreme Court United States circa 1989 Westlaw flag 87
Tomkins v Public Service Electric & Gas Co 568 F2d 1044; 16 Fair Empl Prac Cas 22 United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit United States 23 Nov 1977 WorldLII flag 16
Vance v Southern Bell Telephone and Telegraph Co 863 F2d 1503; 48 Empl Prac Dec P 38,626; 50 Fair Empl Prac Cas 742 United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit United States 23 Jan 1989 WorldLII flag 33
Ways v City of Lincoln 871 F2d 750; 49 Empl Prac Dec P 38,908; 49 Fair Empl Prac Cas 865; 57 USLW 2643 United States Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit United States 3 Apr 1989 WorldLII flag 8
Williams v Cerberonics, Inc 871 F2d 452; 49 Empl Prac Dec P 38,856; 49 Fair Empl Prac Cas 695; 57 USLW 2611 United States Court of Appeals, Fourth Circuit United States 13 Apr 1989 WorldLII flag 52
479 US 949 479 US 949; 93 L Ed 2d 383; 107 SCt 434 United States Supreme Court United States circa 1989 Westlaw flag 30
489 US 1020 489 US 1020; 109 SCt 1140; 103 L Ed 2d 201 United States Supreme Court United States circa 1989 Westlaw flag 23
490 US 1110 490 US 1110; 104 L Ed 2d 1028; 109 SCt 3166 United States Supreme Court United States circa 1989 Westlaw flag 34
554 a2d 509 554 A2d 509; 520 PA 617 United States circa 1989 flag 1

LawCite: Privacy | Disclaimers | Conditions of Use | Acknowledgements | Feedback