LawCite Search | LawCite Markup Tool | Help | Feedback

Law
Cite

Cases Referring to this Case | Law Reform Reports Referring to this Case | Law Journal Articles Referring to this Case | Legislation Cited | Cases and Articles Cited

Help

Northern Telecom, Inc v Datapoint Corporation   flag  41

908 F2d 931; 15 USPQ2d 1321; 15 USPQ 2
United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit
United States
27th August, 1990

Cases Referring to this Case

Case Name Citation(s) Court Jurisdiction Date Full Text Citation Index † 
Molins PLC v Textron, Inc 48 F3d 1172; 33 USPQ2d 1823 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 15 Mar 1995 WorldLII flag 72
Amgen, Inc v Chugai Pharmaceutical Co 927 F2d 1200; 59 USLW 2575; 18 USPQ2d 1016; 55 Empl Prac Dec P 40,580; 55 Fair Empl Prac Cas 178 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 20 May 1991 WorldLII flag 63
Modine Mfg Co v United States Int'l Trade Comm'n 75 F3d 1545; 37 USPQ2d 1609 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 5 Feb 1996 WorldLII flag 43
CR Bard, Inc v M3 Sys , Inc 157 F3d 1340 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 30 Sep 1998 WorldLII flag 34
Miles Laboratories Inc v Shandon Inc 997 F2d 870; 27 USPQ2d 1123 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 1 Sep 1993 WorldLII flag 28
Engel Indus , Inc v Lockformer Co 946 F2d 1528; 20 USPQ2d 1300 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 13 Nov 1991 WorldLII flag 24
Applied Materials, Inc v Advanced Semiconductor Materials Am , Inc 98 F3d 1563; 40 USPQ2d 1481 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 17 Dec 1996 WorldLII flag 23
N Telecom Ltd v Samsung Elecs Co 215 F3d 1281 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 13 Jun 2000 WorldLII flag 19
Monarch Knitting Machinery Corporation v Sulzer Morat Gmbh & Usa 139 F3d 877; 45 USPQ2d 1977 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 10 Mar 1998 WorldLII flag 17
Moba Bv Bv Fps v Diamond Automation Inc 325 F3d 1306 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 25 Apr 2003 WorldLII flag 16
Eli Lilly & Co v Barr Labs , Inc 251 F3d 955; 58 USPQ2d 1869 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 30 May 2001 WorldLII flag 14
Atd Corporation v Lydall Inc 159 F3d 534; 48 USPQ2d 1321 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 6 Oct 1998 WorldLII flag 14
Union Oil Co of California, Plaintiff-Appellee, v Atlantic Richfield Co, Chevron USA Inc , Exxon Corporation, Mobil Oil Corporation, Shell Oil Products Co and Texaco Refining and Marketing, Inc , Defendants-Appellants United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit 208 F3d 989 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 29 Mar 2000 WorldLII flag 12
Interspiro Usa Inc Usa Usa v Figgie International Inc 62 USLW 2595 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 8 Mar 1994 WorldLII flag 12
Interspiro Usa Inc Usa Usa v Figgie International Inc 62 USLW 2595 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 8 Mar 1994 WorldLII flag 12
Tol-O-Matic Inc v Proma Produkt-Und Marketing Gesellschaft 945 F2d 1546; 20 USPQ2d 1332 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 26 Sep 1991 WorldLII flag 12
Hyatt v Boone 146 F3d 1348; 47 USPQ2d 1128 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 26 Aug 1998 WorldLII flag 11
National Recovery Technologies Inc v Magnetic Separation Systems Inc R 166 F3d 1190; 49 USPQ2d 1671 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 4 Feb 1999 WorldLII flag 10
Vulcan Engineering Co Inc v Fata Aluminium Inc 278 F3d 1366 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 5 Feb 2002 WorldLII flag 9
Semiconductor Energy Lab Co v Samsung Elecs Co 204 F3d 1368 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 2 Mar 2000 WorldLII flag 9
Heidelberger Druckmaschinen Ag v Hantscho Commercial Products Inc 21 F3d 1068; 30 USPQ2d 1377 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 1 Jun 1994 WorldLII flag 9
Typeright Keyboard Corporation v Microsoft Corporation 374 F3d 1151 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 6 Jul 2004 WorldLII flag 8
Asyst Techs , Inc v Emtrak, Inc 402 F3d 1188 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 22 Mar 2005 WorldLII flag 7
Cooper Cameron Corporation v Kvaerner Oilfield Products Inc 291 F3d 1317 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 11 Jul 2002 WorldLII flag 7
Asyst Technologies, Inc , Plaintiff-Appellant, v Empak, Inc , Defendant, and Emtrak, Inc , Jenoptik AG, Jenoptik Infab, Inc , Jenoptik GMBH and Infab US Operations, Inc , and Meissner & Wurst, Defendants-Appellees 268 F3d 1364 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 10 Oct 2001 WorldLII flag 6
Karsten Manufacturing Corporation, Plaintiff-Appellant, v Cleveland Golf Co, Defendant-Appellee 242 F3d 1376 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 22 Mar 2001 WorldLII flag 6
Ferring Bv Aventis Pharmaceuticals Inc v Barr Laboratories Inc 437 F3d 1181 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 15 Feb 2006 WorldLII flag 5
Hupp v Siroflex of America Inc 122 F3d 1456; 43 USPQ2d 1887 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 4 Sep 1997 WorldLII flag 5
Magnivision Inc v Bonneau Co 115 F3d 956; 42 USPQ2d 1925 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 8 Aug 1997 WorldLII flag 5
Ultradent Products Inc v Life-Like Cosmetics Inc F 127 F3d 1065; 44 USPQ2d 1336 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 10 Oct 1997 WorldLII flag 4
Re Paul Chu William Downs John B Doyle and Peter v Smith 66 F3d 292; 36 USPQ2d 1089 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 14 Sep 1995 WorldLII flag 4
Bayer Ag v Schein Pharmaceuticals Inc 301 F3d 1306 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 18 Oct 2002 WorldLII flag 2
Eli Lilly and Co, Plaintiff-Cross Appellant, v Barr Laboratories, Inc , and Apotex, Inc and Bernard C Sherman, and Geneva Pharmaceuticals, Inc , Defendants-Appellants, and Interpharm, Inc , Defendant 222 F3d 973; 55 USPQ2d 1609 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 9 Aug 2000 WorldLII flag 2
High Concrete Structures Inc v New Enterprise Stone and Lime Co Inc 377 F3d 1379 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 27 Sep 2004 WorldLII flag 1
Eagles Tool Warehouse Inc v Fisher Tooling Co Inc 439 F3d 1335 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 22 Mar 2006 WorldLII flag
Bristol-Myers Squibb Co v Pharmachemie Bv 361 F3d 1343 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 21 Apr 2004 WorldLII flag
Oglesby Plant Laboratories Inc v Atkinson Exotica Internacional Sa [1996] USCAFED 614 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 6 Jun 1996 WorldLII flag
Re Joan Stevens Peter P Van Daele and Roeland G Baets [1994] USCAFED 322 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 12 Apr 1994 WorldLII flag

Law Journal Articles Referring to this Case

Journal Article Title Citation(s) Author Jurisdiction Date Full Text Citation Index † 
"The Software Patent Thicket: A Matter Of Disclosure" (2009) 62 SCRIPT-ed 207 R M Ballardini United Kingdom circa 2009 BAILII flag
"Evolution of Industry Knowledge in the Public Domain: Prior Art Searching for Software Patents" (2005) 21 SCRIPT-ed 47 J Park United Kingdom circa 2005 BAILII flag

Cases and Articles Cited

Case Name Citation(s) Court Jurisdiction Date Full Text Citation Index † 
United States v Cohen 888 F2d 770; 29 Fed REvid Serv 182 United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit United States 15 Nov 1989 WorldLII flag 20
N Telecom Ltd v Samsung Elecs Co 215 F3d 1281 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 13 Jun 2000 WorldLII flag 19
778 f2d 1571; (1576) 228 Uspq 32 778 F2d 1571; (1576) 228 USPQ 32 United States circa 1576 Westlaw flag 19
Monarch Knitting Machinery Corporation v Sulzer Morat Gmbh & Usa 139 F3d 877; 45 USPQ2d 1977 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 10 Mar 1998 WorldLII flag 17
Moba Bv Bv Fps v Diamond Automation Inc 325 F3d 1306 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 25 Apr 2003 WorldLII flag 16
613 f2d 809 613 F2d 809 United States circa 2003 Westlaw flag 16
615 f2d 809 615 F2d 809; 204 USPQ 537 United States circa 2003 Westlaw flag 15
Garrett Corporation v United States 422 F2d 874; 190 Ct Cl 858; 164 USPQ 521; 422 FED 874; 190 Cl Ct 858 United States circa 2003 Westlaw flag 15
Eli Lilly & Co v Barr Labs , Inc 251 F3d 955; 58 USPQ2d 1869 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 30 May 2001 WorldLII flag 14
Atd Corporation v Lydall Inc 159 F3d 534; 48 USPQ2d 1321 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 6 Oct 1998 WorldLII flag 14
White Consolidated Industries Inc v Vega Servo-Control Inc 713 F2d 788; 218 USPQ 961 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 25 Jul 1983 WorldLII flag 14
Re Leo M Hall 781 F2d 897; 228 USPQ 453 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 16 Jan 1986 WorldLII flag 13
Union Oil Co of California, Plaintiff-Appellee, v Atlantic Richfield Co, Chevron USA Inc , Exxon Corporation, Mobil Oil Corporation, Shell Oil Products Co and Texaco Refining and Marketing, Inc , Defendants-Appellants United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit 208 F3d 989 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 29 Mar 2000 WorldLII flag 12
Interspiro Usa Inc Usa Usa v Figgie International Inc 62 USLW 2595 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 8 Mar 1994 WorldLII flag 12
Interspiro Usa Inc Usa Usa v Figgie International Inc 62 USLW 2595 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 8 Mar 1994 WorldLII flag 12
Tol-O-Matic Inc v Proma Produkt-Und Marketing Gesellschaft 945 F2d 1546; 20 USPQ2d 1332 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 26 Sep 1991 WorldLII flag 12
Hyatt v Boone 146 F3d 1348; 47 USPQ2d 1128 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 26 Aug 1998 WorldLII flag 11
In re Wyer 655 F2d 221; 210 USPQ 790 United States circa 1998 Westlaw flag 11
National Recovery Technologies Inc v Magnetic Separation Systems Inc R 166 F3d 1190; 49 USPQ2d 1671 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 4 Feb 1999 WorldLII flag 10
Vulcan Engineering Co Inc v Fata Aluminium Inc 278 F3d 1366 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 5 Feb 2002 WorldLII flag 9
Semiconductor Energy Lab Co v Samsung Elecs Co 204 F3d 1368 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 2 Mar 2000 WorldLII flag 9
Heidelberger Druckmaschinen Ag v Hantscho Commercial Products Inc 21 F3d 1068; 30 USPQ2d 1377 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 1 Jun 1994 WorldLII flag 9
Typeright Keyboard Corporation v Microsoft Corporation 374 F3d 1151 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 6 Jul 2004 WorldLII flag 8
Asyst Techs , Inc v Emtrak, Inc 402 F3d 1188 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 22 Mar 2005 WorldLII flag 7
Cooper Cameron Corporation v Kvaerner Oilfield Products Inc 291 F3d 1317 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 11 Jul 2002 WorldLII flag 7
Re Edward L Benno 768 F2d 1340; 226 USPQ 683 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 26 Jul 1985 WorldLII flag 7
Asyst Technologies, Inc , Plaintiff-Appellant, v Empak, Inc , Defendant, and Emtrak, Inc , Jenoptik AG, Jenoptik Infab, Inc , Jenoptik GMBH and Infab US Operations, Inc , and Meissner & Wurst, Defendants-Appellees 268 F3d 1364 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 10 Oct 2001 WorldLII flag 6
Karsten Manufacturing Corporation, Plaintiff-Appellant, v Cleveland Golf Co, Defendant-Appellee 242 F3d 1376 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 22 Mar 2001 WorldLII flag 6
276 f2d 393 276 F2d 393; 47 CCPA 866; 125 USPQ 328 United States circa 2001 Westlaw flag 6
Ferring Bv Aventis Pharmaceuticals Inc v Barr Laboratories Inc 437 F3d 1181 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 15 Feb 2006 WorldLII flag 5
Hupp v Siroflex of America Inc 122 F3d 1456; 43 USPQ2d 1887 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 4 Sep 1997 WorldLII flag 5
Magnivision Inc v Bonneau Co 115 F3d 956; 42 USPQ2d 1925 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 8 Aug 1997 WorldLII flag 5
Ultradent Products Inc v Life-Like Cosmetics Inc F 127 F3d 1065; 44 USPQ2d 1336 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 10 Oct 1997 WorldLII flag 4
Re Paul Chu William Downs John B Doyle and Peter v Smith 66 F3d 292; 36 USPQ2d 1089 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 14 Sep 1995 WorldLII flag 4
Massachusetts Institute of Technology v Ab Fortia Ab Ab US 774 F2d 1104; 227 USPQ 428; 7 ITRD 1405 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 7 Oct 1985 WorldLII flag 4
In re Karnofsky 390 F2d 994 United States circa 1995 Westlaw flag 3
156 Uspq 682 156 USPQ 682; 55 CCPA 940 United States circa 1995 flag 3
102 VI 103 102 VI 103 circa 1995 3
Dana Corporation v IPC Ltd Partnership 60 F2d 415; 8 USPQ2d 1692 United States circa 1995 Westlaw flag 3
Bayer Ag v Schein Pharmaceuticals Inc 301 F3d 1306 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 18 Oct 2002 WorldLII flag 2
Eli Lilly and Co, Plaintiff-Cross Appellant, v Barr Laboratories, Inc , and Apotex, Inc and Bernard C Sherman, and Geneva Pharmaceuticals, Inc , Defendants-Appellants, and Interpharm, Inc , Defendant 222 F3d 973; 55 USPQ2d 1609 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 9 Aug 2000 WorldLII flag 2
High Concrete Structures Inc v New Enterprise Stone and Lime Co Inc 377 F3d 1379 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 27 Sep 2004 WorldLII flag 1
"The Software Patent Thicket: A Matter Of Disclosure" (2009) 62 SCRIPT-ed 207 R M Ballardini United Kingdom circa 2009 BAILII flag
Eagles Tool Warehouse Inc v Fisher Tooling Co Inc 439 F3d 1335 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 22 Mar 2006 WorldLII flag
"Evolution of Industry Knowledge in the Public Domain: Prior Art Searching for Software Patents" (2005) 21 SCRIPT-ed 47 J Park United Kingdom circa 2005 BAILII flag
Bristol-Myers Squibb Co v Pharmachemie Bv 361 F3d 1343 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 21 Apr 2004 WorldLII flag
Oglesby Plant Laboratories Inc v Atkinson Exotica Internacional Sa [1996] USCAFED 614 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 6 Jun 1996 WorldLII flag
Re Joan Stevens Peter P Van Daele and Roeland G Baets [1994] USCAFED 322 United States Court of Appeals, Federal Circuit United States 12 Apr 1994 WorldLII flag

LawCite: Privacy | Disclaimers | Conditions of Use | Acknowledgements | Feedback