LawCite Search | LawCite Markup Tool | Help | Feedback Law Cite

Wigberto E TA Ñ Ada and Anna Dominique Coseteng, as members of the Philippine Senate and as taxpayers; Gregorio Andolana and Joker Arroyo as members of the House of Representatives and as taxpayers; Nicanor P Perlas and Horacio R Morales, both as taxpayers; Civil Liberties Union, National Economic Protectionism Association, Center for Alternative Development Initiatives, Likas-Kayang Kaunlaran Foundation, Inc , Philippine Rural Reconstruction Movement, Demokratikong Kilusan NG Magbubukid NG Pilipinas, Inc , and Philippine Peasant Institute, in representation of various taxpayers and as non-governmental organizations v Edgardo Angara, Alberto Romulo, Leticia Ramos-Shahani, Heherson Alvarez, Agapito Aquino, Rodolfo Biazon, Neptali Gonzales, Ernesto Herrera, Jose Lina, Gloria MacApagal-Arroyo, Orlando Mercado, Blas Ople, John Osme Ñ a, Santanina Rasul, Ramon Revilla, Raul Roco, Francisco Tatad and Freddie Webb, in their respective capacities as members of the Philippine Senate who concurred in the ratification by the President of the Philippines of the Agreement Establishing the World Trade Organization; Salvador Enriquez, in his capacity as Secretary of Budget and Management; Caridad Valdehuesa, in her capacity as National Treasurer; Rizalino Navarro, in his capacity as Secretary of Trade and Industry; Roberto Sebastian, in his capacity as Secretary of Agriculture; Roberto De Ocampo, in his capacity as Secretary of Finance; Roberto Romulo, in his capacity as Secretary of Foreign Affairs; and Teofisto t Guingona, in his capacity as Executive Secretary    

Cases and Articles Cited

Case Name	Citation(s)	Court	Jurisdiction †	Date	Full Text		Citation Index
Aquino vs Enrile	59 SCRA 183	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines				51
243 Scra 473	243 SCRA 473	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines				2
Bondoc v Pineda	201 SCRA 792	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines				10
Basco v Pagcor	197 SCRA 52	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines				46
Civil Service Commission	192 SCRA 84	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines				20
Bustamante vs Commissioner on Audit	216 SCRA 134	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines				17
Commissioner of Internal Revenue v Court of Tax Appeals	195 SCRA 444	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines				10
Daza v Singson	180 SCRA 496	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines				20
Guingona v Gonzales	219 SCRA 326	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines				7
KMU Labor Center v Garcia, Jr	239 SCRA 386	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines				19
Kilosbayan, Inc vs Morato	246 SCRA 540	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines				37
Oposa v Factoran	224 SCRA 792	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines				39
Reagan v Commissioner	30 SCRA 968	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines				15
San Sebastian College v Court of Appeals	197 SCRA 138	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines				10
Sinon v Civil Service Commission	215 SCRA 410	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines				22
Tanada v Cuenco	103 Phil 1051		Philippines				50
8 Page 6	8 Page 6		United Kingdom				19
27 Sec 10	27 SEC 10		United States				6
28 Sec 12	28 SEC 12		United States				8
29 Sec 19	29 SEC 19		United States				5
30 Sec 13	30 SEC 13		United States				4
32 Sec 1	32 SEC 1		United States				12
37 Sec 13	37 SEC 13		United States				3
39 Public Administration Review 4	39 Public Administration Review 4	Public Administration Review	United States				2
41 Sec 24	41 SEC 24		United States				2
43 Sec 2	43 SEC 2		United States				12
5 Sec 5	5 SEC 5		United States				39
Comelec Rules of Procedure , Rule	35 SEC 19		United States				7
64 Sec 21	64 SEC 21		United States				2
20 Public Administration Review 4	20 Public Administration Review 4	Public Administration Review	United States				4
52 PS 1083	52 PS 1083						2