LawCite Search | LawCite Markup Tool | Help | Feedback

Law
Cite

Cases Referring to this Case | Law Reform Reports Referring to this Case | Law Journal Articles Referring to this Case | Legislation Cited | Cases and Articles Cited

Help

Alvarez-Machain v United States   flag  16

331 F3d 604
United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit
United States
3rd June, 2003

Cases Referring to this Case

Case Name Citation(s) Court Jurisdiction Date †  Full Text Citation Index
Sarei v Rio Tinto, PLC 487 F3d 1193 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 12 Apr 2007 WorldLII flag 7
Alvarez-Machain v United States 374 F3d 1384 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 14 Jul 2004 WorldLII flag
Sosa v Alvarez-Machain 542 US 692; 124 SCt 2739; 159 L Ed 2d 718 United States Supreme Court United States 29 Jun 2004 WorldLII flag 91
Erlin v United States 364 F3d 1127 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 19 Apr 2004 WorldLII flag 3
United States v Alvarez-MacHain [2003] USSC 8392 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Dec 2003 WorldLII flag
Schriro v Summerlin [2003] USSC 8342 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Dec 2003 WorldLII flag

Law Journal Articles Referring to this Case

Journal Article Title Citation(s) Author Jurisdiction Date †  Full Text Citation Index
Developments in the Law †Access to Courts (2009) 122 Harvard Law Review 1151 Harvard Law Review United States 1 Jan 2009 WorldLII flag
"Reflections on A Convenient Untruth" (2008) 48 Virginia Journal of International Law 641 Weisburd, A Mark United States circa 2008 WorldLII flag
DC Circuit Holds Claims of Harms to Native Inhabitants of the British Indian Ocean Territory Caused by the Construction of a US Military Base Nonjusticiable (2007) 120 Harvard Law Review 860 Harvard Law Review United States 1 Jan 2007 WorldLII flag
"SOSA, Customary International Law, and the Continuing Relevance of Erie" (2007) 120 Harvard Law Review 869 Bradley, Curtis A; Goldsmith, Jack L; Moore, David H United States 1 Jan 2007 WorldLII flag 6
Law's Migration: American Exceptionalism, Silent Dialogues, and Federalism's Multiple Ports of Entry 115 Yale Law Journal 1564 Resnik, Judith United States 1 Jan 2006 WorldLII flag 8
"Regulating Multi-national Corporations through State-based Laws: Problems with Enforcing Human Rights Torts under the United States Alien Tort Statute" (2006) 13 Australian International Law Journal 233 Harpur, Paul Australia circa 2006 AustLII flag
"The Recent History of the Alien Tort Claims Act: Australia's Role in its (attempted) Downfall" (2006) 25 Australian Year Book of International Law 139 O'Rourke, Anne; Nyland, Chris Australia circa 2006 AustLII flag
"Review Article Of: The Ethics and Politics of Asylum: Liberal Democracy and the Response to Refugees" (2005) 11 Australian Journal of Human Rights 9 Dixon, Rosalind Australia circa 2005 AustLII flag
"Sources of Doubt, Sources of Duty: HLA Hart on International Law" (2005) 10 Deakin Law Review 698 Morss, John R Australia circa 2005 AustLII flag
"Table of Cases" [2004] AURELawJl 87 Editors Australia circa 2004 AustLII flag

Legislation Cited

Legislation Name Provision
Constitution

Cases and Articles Cited

Case Name Citation(s) Court Jurisdiction Date †  Full Text Citation Index
United States v Yousef 327 F3d 56 United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit United States 4 Apr 2003 WorldLII flag 57
Al Odah v United States 321 F3d 1134 United States Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit United States 11 Mar 2003 WorldLII flag 24
United States v Neil 312 F3d 419 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 20 Nov 2002 WorldLII flag 3
Kasi v J Angelone 300 F3d 487 United States Court of Appeals, Fourth Circuit United States 15 Aug 2002 WorldLII flag 3
Orsay US US v United States Department of Justice 289 F3d 1125 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 14 May 2002 WorldLII flag 9
Alvarez-Machain v United States 284 F3d 1039 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 20 Mar 2002 WorldLII flag 1
Papa v United States 281 F3d 1004 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 25 Feb 2002 WorldLII flag 19
United States v Hill 279 F3d 731 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 29 Jan 2002 WorldLII flag 8
"Apprehension of War Crimes Indictees: Should the United Nations' Courts Outsource Private Actors to Catch Them?" (2002) 51 Catholic University Law Review 619 Catholic University Law Review United States circa 2002 HeinOnline / LexisNexis flag 1
United States of America, Plaintiff-Appellee, v William R Stephens, Defendant-Appellant 237 F3d 1031 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 16 Jan 2001 WorldLII flag 6
United States of America, Plaintiff-Appellee, v Clifton S Corey, Defendant-Appellant 232 F3d 1166 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 20 Nov 2000 WorldLII flag 10
Vickers v United States 228 F3d 944 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 3 Oct 2000 WorldLII flag 9
Nurse v United States 226 F3d 996 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 12 Sep 2000 WorldLII flag 14
Abogados v AT & T, Inc 223 F3d 932 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 2 Aug 2000 WorldLII flag 7
United States of America, Appellee, v Milton Gatlin, Defendant-Appellant 216 F3d 207 United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit United States 15 Jun 2000 WorldLII flag 8
Beanal v Freeport-McMoran, Inc 197 F3d 161 United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit United States 29 Nov 1999 WorldLII flag 19
Townes v City of New York 176 F3d 138 United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit United States 6 May 1999 WorldLII flag 20
Martinez v City of Los Angeles 141 F3d 1373 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 21 Apr 1998 WorldLII flag 11
Re Fred Di Giorgio 134 F3d 971 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 22 Jan 1998 WorldLII flag 8
Chan v Society Expeditions Inc Chan 123 F3d 1287; [1997] AMC 2713 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 29 Aug 1997 WorldLII flag 10
United States v Noriega 117 F3d 1206 United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit United States 7 Jul 1997 WorldLII flag 19
Couzado v United States Drug Enforcement Administration of the Department of Justice 105 F3d 1389 United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit United States 20 Feb 1997 WorldLII flag 4
Alvarez-Machain v United States 107 F3d 696 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 19 Feb 1997 WorldLII flag 21
Maximo Hilao v Estate of Ferdinand Marcos 103 F3d 789 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 17 Dec 1996 WorldLII flag 6
Hilao v Estate of Marcos 103 F3d 767 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 17 Dec 1996 WorldLII flag 41
Pescatore v Pan American World Airways Inc 97 F3d 1; 45 Fed REvid Serv 624 United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit United States 9 Sep 1996 WorldLII flag 28
Freedom to Travel Campaign v Newcomb 82 F3d 1431 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 29 Apr 1996 WorldLII flag 16
Bickel v Korean Air Lines Co Ltd 83 F3d 127; 64 USLW 2693; [1996] AMC 1541 United States Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit United States 29 Apr 1996 WorldLII flag 11
Zicherman v Korean Air Lines Co 516 US 217; 133 L Ed 2d 596; 116 SCt 629 United States Supreme Court United States 16 Jan 1996 WorldLII flag 55
Kadic v Karadzic 70 F3d 232; 64 USLW 2231 United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit United States 6 Jan 1996 WorldLII flag 76
United States v Matta-Ballesteros 71 F3d 754 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 1 Dec 1995 WorldLII flag 54
Rhoden v United States 55 F3d 428 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 15 May 1995 WorldLII flag 13
United States v Khan 35 F3d 426 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 17 Nov 1994 WorldLII flag 17
Kollias v D & G Marine Maintenance B & a Marine Co 29 F3d 67; 63 USLW 2044 United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit United States 6 Jul 1994 WorldLII flag 11
Heck v Humphrey 512 US 477; 129 L Ed 2d 383; 114 SCt 2364 United States Supreme Court United States 24 Jun 1994 WorldLII flag 703
Estate of Ferdinand Marcos Human Rights Litigation Hilao v Estate of Marcos 25 F3d 1467 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 16 Jun 1994 WorldLII flag 48
O'Melveny & Myers v FDIC 512 US 79; 129 L Ed 2d 67; 114 SCt 2048 United States Supreme Court United States 13 Jun 1994 WorldLII flag 129
United States v Vasquez-Velasco 15 F3d 833 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 25 Jan 1994 WorldLII flag 50
Smith v United States 507 US 197; 122 L Ed 2d 548; 113 SCt 1178 United States Supreme Court United States 8 Mar 1993 WorldLII flag 40
Estate of Ferdinand Marcos Human Rights Litigation Trajano v E Marcos 978 F2d 493; 61 USLW 2257; 116 ALRFed 765 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 21 Oct 1992 WorldLII flag 39
United States v Lopez-Alvarez 970 F2d 583; 36 Fed REvid Serv 51 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 8 Jul 1992 WorldLII flag 75
Blake v Republic of Argentina 965 F2d 699; 60 USLW 2771 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 22 May 1992 WorldLII flag 75
United States v Alvarez-Machain 946 F2d 1466 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 18 Oct 1991 WorldLII flag 7
United States v Alvarez-Machain 939 F2d 1341; 112 SCt 2188; 119 L Ed 2d 441 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 22 Jul 1991 WorldLII flag 47
United States v Felix-Gutierrez 940 F2d 1200 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 22 Jul 1991 WorldLII flag 43
Kamen v Kemper Financial Services, Inc 500 US 90; 114 L Ed 2d 152; 111 SCt 1711 United States Supreme Court United States 20 May 1991 WorldLII flag 115
Schoenberg v Exportadora Sal Sa Cv S Schoenberg 930 F2d 777 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 19 Apr 1991 WorldLII flag 19
United States v Gaubert 499 US 315; 113 L Ed 2d 335; 111 SCt 1267 United States Supreme Court United States 26 Mar 1991 WorldLII flag 209
EEOC v Arabian American Oil Co 499 US 244; 113 L Ed 2d 274; 111 SCt 1227 United States Supreme Court United States 26 Mar 1991 WorldLII flag 155
United States v Smith 499 US 160; 113 L Ed 2d 134; 111 SCt 1180 United States Supreme Court United States 20 Mar 1991 WorldLII flag 67
Ting v United States 927 F2d 1504 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 14 Mar 1991 WorldLII flag 36
United States v Verdugo-Urquidez 494 US 259; 108 L Ed 2d 222; 110 SCt 1056 United States Supreme Court United States 16 Apr 1990 WorldLII flag 106
Department of Labor v Triplett 494 US 715; 108 L Ed 2d 701; 110 SCt 1428 United States Supreme Court United States 27 Mar 1990 WorldLII flag 41
Matta-Ballesteros v Henman 896 F2d 255 United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit United States 22 Feb 1990 WorldLII flag 48
Barts v Joyner 865 F2d 1187; 57 USLW 2471 United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit United States 1 Mar 1989 WorldLII flag 44
Mistretta v United States 488 US 361; 102 L Ed 2d 714; 109 SCt 647 United States Supreme Court United States 18 Jan 1989 WorldLII flag 763
United States v Verdugo-Urquidez 856 F2d 1214; 57 USLW 2152 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 29 Aug 1988 WorldLII flag 12
Hand v Gary 838 F2d 1420 United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit United States 10 Mar 1988 WorldLII flag 32
Cominotto v United States 802 F2d 1127 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 17 Oct 1986 WorldLII flag 10
Garcia-Mir v Meese 788 F2d 1446; 54 USLW 2561 United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit United States 23 Apr 1986 WorldLII flag 22
De Sanchez v Banco Central De Nicaragua a 770 F2d 1385; 54 USLW 2230 United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit United States 19 Sep 1985 WorldLII flag 31
Arnsberg v United States 757 F2d 971 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 9 Apr 1985 WorldLII flag 47
Chua Han Mow v United States 730 F2d 1308 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 12 Apr 1984 WorldLII flag 57
Tel-Oren v Libyan Arab Republic 726 F2d 774; 233 USApp DC 384 United States Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit United States 3 Feb 1984 WorldLII flag 57
Smiddy v Varney 665 F2d 261 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 21 Dec 1981 WorldLII flag 58
Rodriguez-Fernandez v Wilkinson 654 F2d 1382 United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit United States 9 Jul 1981 WorldLII flag 27
Texas Industries, Inc v Radcliff Materials, Inc 451 US 630; 101 SCt 2061; 68 L Ed 2d 500 United States Supreme Court United States 26 May 1981 WorldLII flag 186
Filartiga v Pena-Irala 630 F2d 876; 2d CR 1980 United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit United States 30 Jun 1980 WorldLII flag 127
Sami v United States 617 F2d 755; 199 USApp DC 173; 57 ALRFed 245 United States Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit United States 28 Dec 1979 WorldLII flag 34
Singleton v Wulff 428 US 106; 49 L Ed 2d 826; 96 SCt 2868 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Jul 1976 WorldLII flag 1010
IIT v Vencap, Ltd 519 F2d 1001 United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit United States 28 Apr 1975 WorldLII flag 59
Gilligan v Morgan 413 US 1; 37 L Ed 2d 407; 93 SCt 2440 United States Supreme Court United States 21 Jun 1973 WorldLII flag 122
Bivens v Six Unknown Named Agents of Federal Bureau of Narcotics 403 US 388; 29 L Ed 2d 619; 91 SCt 1999; 29 L Ed 2; 29 L Ed 619 United States Supreme Court United States 21 Jun 1971 WorldLII flag 2207
United States of America v Arthur Ronald Decatur 430 F2d 365 United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit United States 20 Jul 1970 WorldLII flag 5
US and Australian Governments (1969) 1144 UNTS 123 International circa 1969 flag 121
Civil and Political Rights (1966) 999 UNTS 171 International circa 1966 flag 1329
Zemel v Rusk 381 US 1; 14 L Ed 2d 179; 85 SCt 1271 United States Supreme Court United States 11 Oct 1965 WorldLII flag 199
Cuba v Sabbatino 376 US 398; 11 L Ed 2d 804; 84 SCt 923; 35 ILR 2; 11 L Ed 804; 193 FSupp 375 United States Supreme Court United States 23 Mar 1964 WorldLII flag 299
McCulloch v Sociedad Nacional 372 US 10; 9 L Ed 2d 547; 83 SCt 671 United States Supreme Court United States 18 Feb 1963 WorldLII flag 155
Rusk v Cort 369 US 367; 7 L Ed 2d 809; 82 SCt 787; 7 L Ed 2 United States Supreme Court United States 2 Apr 1962 WorldLII flag 270
Baker v Carr 369 US 186; 82 SCt 691; 7 L Ed 2d 633; 7 L Ed 663; 82 SCt Rep 69; 7 L Ed 2; 7 L Ed 2d 663 United States Supreme Court United States 26 Mar 1962 WorldLII flag 1055
Johnson v Eisentrager 339 US 763; 94 L Ed 1255; 70 SCt 936; 94 L Ed 2d 1255 United States Supreme Court United States 5 Jun 1950 WorldLII flag 128
Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (1950) 213 UNTS 222 International circa 1950 flag 140
Foley Bros v Filardo 336 US 281; 93 L Ed 680; 69 SCt 575 United States Supreme Court United States 7 Mar 1949 WorldLII flag 89
Ludecke v Watkins 335 US 160; 92 L Ed 1881; 68 SCt 1429 United States Supreme Court United States 11 Oct 1948 WorldLII flag 58
Chicago & Southern Air Lines, Inc v Waterman Steamship Corporation 333 US 103; 92 L Ed 568; 68 SCt 431 United States Supreme Court United States 13 Apr 1948 WorldLII flag 280
Ex parte Republic of Peru 318 US 578; 87 L Ed 1014; 63 SCt 793 United States Supreme Court United States 5 Apr 1943 WorldLII flag 136
Guaranty Trust Co v United States 304 US 126; 82 L Ed 1224; 58 SCt 785; 82 L Ed 2d 1224 United States Supreme Court United States 25 Apr 1938 WorldLII flag 123
United States v Curtiss-Wright Export Corporation 299 US 304; 81 L Ed 2d 255; 81 L Ed 255; 57 SCt 216 United States Supreme Court United States 21 Dec 1936 WorldLII flag 229
United States v Bowman 260 US 94; 67 L Ed 149; 43 SCt 39; 67 L Ed 2d 149 United States Supreme Court United States 13 Nov 1922 WorldLII flag 81
Oetjen v Central Leather Co 246 US 276; 38 SCt 237; 62 L Ed 713 United States Supreme Court United States 11 Mar 1918 WorldLII flag 55
O'Reilly De Camara v Brooke 209 US 45; 52 L Ed 676; 28 SCt 439 United States Supreme Court United States 16 Mar 1908 WorldLII flag 11
Paquete Habana 425 F3d 367; 20 SCt 290; 92 Idaho 93 United States Supreme Court United States 8 Jan 1900 WorldLII flag 114
In re Baiz 135 US 403; 34 L Ed 222; 10 SCt 854 United States Supreme Court United States 5 May 1890 WorldLII flag 16
Ker v Illinois 119 US 436; 30 L Ed 421; 30 L Ed 2d 421; 7 SCt 225 United States Supreme Court United States 6 Dec 1886 WorldLII flag 140
Apollon 22 US 362; 9 Wheat 362; 6 L Ed 111 United States Supreme Court United States 17 Mar 1824 WorldLII flag 47
United States v Smith 18 US 153; 5 Wheat 153; 5 L Ed 57 United States Supreme Court United States 25 Feb 1820 WorldLII flag 48
Schooner Exchange v M'Faddon 11 US 116; 3 L Ed 287; 7 Cranch 116 United States Supreme Court United States 24 Feb 1812 WorldLII flag 189
Alexander Murray v Charming Betsy 6 US 64; 2 Cranch 64; 2 L Ed 208; 6 Cranch 64 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Feb 1804 WorldLII flag 137
Marbury v Madison 5 US 137; 1 Cranch 137; 2 L Ed 135; 2 L Ed 60; 6 Pet 241 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Feb 1803 WorldLII flag 1029
Mossman, Surviving v Higginson, Surviving Partner 4 US 12; 1 L Ed 720; 4 Dall 12 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Feb 1800 WorldLII flag 20
Chisholm v Georgia 2 US 419; 1 L Ed 440; 2 Dall 419 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Feb 1793 WorldLII flag 154
1155 Unts 332 1155 UNTS 332 International flag 18
Beanal v Freeport-McMoRan, Inc 969 FSupp 362 United States Westlaw flag 10
Paul v Avril 901 FSupp 330 United States Westlaw flag 3
Xuncax v Gramajo 886 FSupp 162 United States Westlaw flag 35
United States v Caro-Quintero 745 FSupp 599 United States Westlaw flag 7
Forti v Suarez-Mason 672 FSupp 1531 United States Westlaw flag 26
Filartiga v Pena-Irala 577 FSupp 860 United States Westlaw flag 4
Steel Co v Citizens for a Better Env't 523 US 83; 118 SCt 1003; 140 L Ed 2d 210 United States Supreme Court United States Westlaw flag 662
United States v Alvarez-Machain 504 US 655 United States Supreme Court United States Westlaw flag 54
Atlee v Richardson 411 US 911; 36 L Ed 2d 304; 93 SCt 1545 United States Supreme Court United States Westlaw flag 14
Atlee v Laird 347 FSupp 689 United States Westlaw flag 13
Hamdi v Rumsfeld 316 F3d 450 United States Westlaw flag 17
Alvarez-Machain v United States ("Alvarez-Machain IV") United States Westlaw flag 6
246 US 297 246 US 297 United States Supreme Court United States Westlaw flag 116
USA Found v United States 242 F3d 1300 United States Westlaw flag 12
Tachiona v Mugabe 234 FSupp 2d 401 United States Westlaw flag 3
Mehinovic v Vuckovic 198 FSupp 2d 1322 United States Westlaw flag 10
National Coalition Government of the Union of Burma v Unocal Inc 176 FRD 329 United States flag 7
175 US 677 175 US 677 United States Supreme Court United States Westlaw flag 113
Restructuring the Modern Treaty Power 114 Harvard Law Review 2478 Harvard Law Review United States HeinOnline / LexisNexis flag 2
Doe v Unocal Corporation 110 FSupp 2d 1294 United States Westlaw flag 11
See, e g , People v Monson 105 Cal Rptr 92; 28 Cal App3d 935 United States - California flag 1
Work of the Sixth Committee at the Forty-Eighth Session of the UN General Assembly 88 American Journal of International Law 343 American Journal of International Law United States HeinOnline / Westlaw flag 1
International Law as Law in the United States 82 Michigan Law Review 1555 Michigan Law Review United States HeinOnline / LexisNexis flag 11
"Judicial Review and the Political Question: A Functional Analysis," 75 Yale Law Journal 517 Yale Law Journal United States HeinOnline / Westlaw flag 16
See, e g , Abebe-Jira v Negewo 72 F3d 844 United States Westlaw flag 20
Gill v Epstein 62 Cal2d 611; 401 P2d 397; 44 Cal Rptr 45 United States - California flag 2
38 SCt 309; 62 l Ed 726 38 SCt 309; 62 L Ed 726 United States Supreme Court United States Westlaw flag 49
Broughton v State 37 NY2d 451; 373 NYS2d 87; 335 NE2d 310 United States - New York flag 34
Alvarez-Machain II, reprinted in 31 International Legal Materials 934 International Legal Materials United States HeinOnline flag 1
28 SCt 439 28 SCt 439 United States Westlaw flag 7
Human and People's Rights (Banjul Charter) 21 International Legal Materials 58 International Legal Materials United States HeinOnline flag 75
Asgari v City of Los Angeles 15 Cal4th 744; 63 Cal Rptr2d 842; 937 P2d 273 United States - California flag 6
7 SCt 225 7 SCt 225 United States Westlaw flag 57
Bolchos v Darrel 3 FCas 810 United States flag 8
3 Dall 199 3 Dall 199 United States flag 46
United States v Chen 2 F3d 330 United States Westlaw flag 4
Ware v Hylton 1 L Ed 568; 4 CR 212 United States Supreme Court United States LexisNexis flag 17
People v Crusilla
91 Cal Rptr2d 415 United States - California flag

LawCite: Privacy | Disclaimers | Conditions of Use | Acknowledgements | Feedback