LawCite Search | LawCite Markup Tool | Help | Feedback Law Cite

Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development v Southern African Litigation Centre (867/15)     68

Cases Referring to this Case

Case Name	Citation(s)	Court	Jurisdiction	Date †	Full Text		Citation Index
- Total Brite Star Service Station CC v Enspa Trading Co (Pty) Ltd (1661/2021)	[2023] ZAECELLC 14		South Africa	6 Jun 2023	SAFLII
JK Structures CC v City of Cape Town (leave to appeal) (14485 / 2021)	[2023] ZAWCHC 93	High Court of South Africa - Western Cape Division	South Africa	8 May 2023	SAFLII
Kunie v Nedbank Ltd (31087/2019)	[2023] ZAGPPHC 256	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	26 Apr 2023	SAFLII
LawCite Kunie v Nedbank Ltd	[2023] ZAGPPHC 839	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	26 Apr 2023	SAFLII
LawCite Ndlala v S	[2023] ZAGPPHC 825	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	18 Apr 2023	SAFLII
LawCite Ndlala v S	[2023] ZAGPPHC 826	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	18 Apr 2023	SAFLII
Independent Community Pharmacy Association v Clicks Group Ltd (CCT 11/22)	[2023] ZACC 10	Constitutional Court of South Africa	South Africa	28 Mar 2023	SAFLII
LawCite Pitja v CCMA (JR2186/21)	[2023] ZALCJHB 79		South Africa	16 Mar 2023	SAFLII
LawCite Dankie Oupa Delwery CC v Commissioner of the South African Revenue Service	[2023] ZAGPPHC 733	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	10 Mar 2023	SAFLII
Dankie Oupa Delwery CC v Commissioner of the South African Revenue Service (39598/20)	[2023] ZAGPPHC 344	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	10 Mar 2023	SAFLII
Raft Crete CC v Pro Team Construction (Pty) Ltd (27017/2020)	[2023] ZAGPPHC 148	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	3 Mar 2023	SAFLII
LawCite Dunn v Minister of Police	[2023] ZAGPPHC 693	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	28 Feb 2023	SAFLII
Dunn v Minister of Police (20946/2016)	[2023] ZAGPPHC 141	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	28 Feb 2023	SAFLII
VBS Mutual Bank (In Liquidation) v Mafoko (2021/34634)	[2023] ZAGPJHC 105	South Gauteng High Court, Johannesburg	South Africa	9 Feb 2023	SAFLII
LawCite Utopia Trade Investments (PTY) Ltd v Stoneridge Investments (PTY) Ltd (D9264/2018)	[2023] ZAKZDHC 4	Kwazulu-Natal High Court, Durban	South Africa - Kwazulu-Natal High Court, Durban	27 Jan 2023	SAFLII
East Asian Consortium, B v v MTN Group Ltd (2013/44462)	[2022] ZAGPJHC 969; 2023 3 SA 77; [2023] 1 All SA 632	South Gauteng High Court, Johannesburg	South Africa	30 Nov 2022	SAFLII
Applications for admission as amicii curiae by various UN bodies and Human Rights Watch: In re certification application by various applicants v Anglo American SA (Ltd) (2020/32777)	[2022] ZAGPJHC 935	South Gauteng High Court, Johannesburg	South Africa	25 Nov 2022	SAFLII
All 4 Security Services CC v City of Cape Town (11496/2021)	[2022] ZAWCHC 236	High Court of South Africa - Western Cape Division	South Africa	18 Nov 2022	SAFLII
Association of Concerned Professional Animal Consultants v The Minister of Agricultural, Forestry (62661/18)	[2022] ZAGPPHC 503	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	14 Jul 2022	SAFLII
King Civil Contractors (PTY) Ltd v Enviroserv Waste Management (PTY) Ltd (45747/2021)	[2022] ZAGPJHC 467	South Gauteng High Court, Johannesburg	South Africa	13 Jul 2022	SAFLII
Real Time Investments 214 CC v Van Straaten (31458/20)	[2022] ZAGPPHC 499	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	7 Jul 2022	SAFLII
Acting Municipal Manager v Madibeng Black Business Chamber (11527/22)	[2022] ZAGPPHC 501	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	5 Jul 2022	SAFLII
Theodosiou v Schindlers Attorneys (14038/2021)	[2022] ZAGPJHC 252	South Gauteng High Court, Johannesburg	South Africa	21 Apr 2022	SAFLII
Phiri v Road Accident Fund (34481 /2018)	[2022] ZAGPJHC 168	South Gauteng High Court, Johannesburg	South Africa	18 Mar 2022	SAFLII
Dancing Beauty and Hair (Pty) Ltd v Northern Centre Shareblock (19633/2021)	[2022] ZAGPJHC 135	South Gauteng High Court, Johannesburg	South Africa	21 Feb 2022	SAFLII
Biyana v Nedbank Ltd (46214/2018)	[2022] ZAGPPHC 57	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	15 Feb 2022	SAFLII
Mhlongo v Farraque (43344/21)	[2022] ZAGPPHC 64	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	15 Feb 2022	SAFLII
Sotshozi v Riaan De Wit Attorneys; Thonga v Riaan De Wit Attorneys; Nohaba v Riaan De Wit Attorneys (991/2019; 1699/2019; 1698/2019)	[2021] ZAECGHC 103	Eastern Cape High Court, Grahamstown	South Africa	25 Nov 2021	SAFLII
Ixia Trading 532 (Pty) Ltd v Auto GP Motors (Pty) Ltd (36584 /2020)	[2021] ZAGPJHC 614	South Gauteng High Court, Johannesburg	South Africa	26 Oct 2021	SAFLII
Chithi; In Re: Luhlwini Mchunu Community v Hancock	[2021] ZASCA 123	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	23 Sep 2021	SAFLII		5
Harnwell v Harnwell (342/2018)	[2021] ZAECGHC 69	Eastern Cape High Court, Grahamstown	South Africa	27 Jul 2021	SAFLII
Nwafor v Minister of Home Affiars	[2021] ZASCA 58	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	12 May 2021	SAFLII		4
Cradock Business Forum v Inxuba Yethemba Local Municipality (2794/2020)	[2021] ZAECGHC 41	Eastern Cape High Court, Grahamstown	South Africa	20 Apr 2021	SAFLII
Financial Sector Conduct Authority v JP Markets SA (Proprietary) Ltd (16017/2020)	[2021] ZAGPJHC 41	South Gauteng High Court, Johannesburg	South Africa	6 Apr 2021	SAFLII
Safintra South Africa (Pty) Ltd v Prince (CA 15/2020)	[2021] ZAECGHC 17	Eastern Cape High Court, Grahamstown	South Africa	22 Feb 2021	SAFLII
LawCite Tansnat Durban (Pty) Ltd v Ethekwini Municipality (D4178/2020)	[2021] ZAKZDHC 3	Kwazulu-Natal High Court, Durban	South Africa - Kwazulu-Natal High Court, Durban	8 Feb 2021	SAFLII
Mbatha v Body Corporate of Carswald Crest (94948/2015)	[2021] ZAGPPHC 91	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	28 Jan 2021	SAFLII
Moko v Acting Principal of Malusi Secondary School (CCT 297/20)	[2020] ZACC 30	Constitutional Court of South Africa	South Africa	28 Dec 2020	SAFLII		2
Cart Blanche Marketing CC v Commissioner for the South African Revenue Service (26244/2015)	[2020] ZAGPJHC 316	South Gauteng High Court, Johannesburg	South Africa	11 Dec 2020	SAFLII
National Union of Metal Workers of South Africa v Dunlop Mixing and Technical Services (Pty) Ltd (6/2020)	[2020] ZASCA 161	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	7 Dec 2020	SAFLII		1
Afribusiness NPC v Minister of Finance	[2020] ZASCA 140; 2021 1 SA 325; [2021] 1 All SA 1	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	2 Nov 2020	SAFLII		6
Turkcell Iletisim Hizetleri AS v MTN Group Ltd	[2020] ZAGPJHC 244	South Gauteng High Court, Johannesburg	South Africa	6 Oct 2020	SAFLII		3
Democratic Alliance v President of the Republic of South Africa	[2020] ZAGPPHC 326	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	29 Jul 2020	SAFLII		13
Independent Institute of Education (Pty) Ltd v University of Sport South Africa (NPO) (76139/17)	[2020] ZAGPPHC 371	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	13 Jul 2020	SAFLII
Unemployed Peoples Movement v Premier for the Province of the Eastern Cape (553/2019)	[2020] ZAECGHC 47	Eastern Cape High Court, Grahamstown	South Africa	21 May 2020	SAFLII
Caratco (Pty) Ltd v Independent Advisory (Pty) Ltd	[2020] ZASCA 17; 2020 5 SA 35	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	25 Mar 2020	SAFLII		27
Nelson Mandela Foundation Trust v Afriforum NPC (EQ02/2018)	[2019] ZAEQC 2; 2019 6 SA 327; 2019 4 All SA 237		South Africa	21 Aug 2019	SAFLII		4
Atakas Ticaret VE Nakliyat AS v Glencore International AG (768/2018)	[2019] ZASCA 77; 2019 5 SA 379	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	30 May 2019	SAFLII
Concorde travel (Pty) Ltd v Travel Today (Pty) Ltd (A647/16, 11780/ 2011)	[2019] ZAGPPHC 155	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	23 May 2019	SAFLII
Dennegeur Estate Home Owners Association v Telkom SA SOC Ltd (366/2018)	[2019] ZASCA 37; 2019 4 SA 451	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	29 Mar 2019	SAFLII		3
Jose v The Minister of Home Affairs (38981/17)	[2019] ZAGPPHC 88; 2019 4 SA 597	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	15 Mar 2019	SAFLII		1
LawCite Absa Bank Ltd v Murray (CA338/2017)	[2018] ZAECGHC 75	Eastern Cape High Court, Grahamstown	South Africa	28 Aug 2018	SAFLII
Kuhudzai v Minister of Home Affairs (11034/16)	[2018] ZAWCHC 103	High Court of South Africa - Western Cape Division	South Africa	24 Aug 2018	SAFLII		2
Endumeni Civic Association v Endumeni Local Municipality (4610/2017)	[2018] ZAKZPHC 43	Kwazulu-Natal High Court, Pietermaritzburg	South Africa	9 Feb 2018	SAFLII
"The Prosecutor v Omar Hassan Ahmad Al - Bashir, International Criminal Court, July 2017" (Vol 1)	[2018] DEJURE 12	Swanepoel, C	South Africa	circa 2018	SAFLII
Zuma v Democratic Alliance; Acting National DPP v Democratic Alliance	[2017] ZASCA 146; 2018 1 SA 200	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	13 Oct 2017	SAFLII		29
Moti v President of the Republic of South Africa	[2017] ZAGPPHC 501	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	18 Aug 2017	SAFLII		1
Kanku v Grindrod Fuelogic (C602/2014)	[2017] ZALCCT 26		South Africa	21 Jun 2017	SAFLII		1
Saharawi Arab Democratic Republic v Owner and Charterers of the MV 'NM Cherry Blossom' (15/6/2017)	[2017] ZAECPEHC 31; 2017 5 SA 105; [2018] 1 All SA 593	Eastern Cape High Court, Port Elizabeth	South Africa	15 Jun 2017	SAFLII		7
Reed v Minister of Finance (30832/2015)	[2017] ZAGPPHC 916	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	2 Jun 2017	SAFLII
Earthlife Africa Johannesburg v Minister of Energy (19529/2015)	[2017] ZAWCHC 50; 2017 5 SA 227; [2017] 3 All SA 187	High Court of South Africa - Western Cape Division	South Africa	26 Apr 2017	SAFLII		6
Da Cruz v City of Cape Town (6562/2015)	[2017] ZAWCHC 169	High Court of South Africa - Western Cape Division	South Africa	10 Mar 2017	SAFLII
Democratic Alliance v Minister of International Relations and Cooperation (Council for the Advancement of the South African Constitution Intervening) (83145/2016)	[2017] ZAGPPHC 53; 2017 3 SA 212; 2017 1 SACR 623; [2017] 2 All SA 123	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	22 Feb 2017	SAFLII		7
Mahem Verhurings CC v Firstrand Bank Ltd (91998/2015)	[2017] ZAGPPHC 167	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	8 Feb 2017	SAFLII		1
Motata v Minister of Justice and Correctional Services (52010/2016)	[2016] ZAGPPHC 1063; [2017] 1 All SA 924	North Gauteng High Court, Pretoria	South Africa	30 Dec 2016	SAFLII		2
Primedia Broadcasting (a division of Primedia (Pty) Ltd) v Speaker of the National Assembly (784/2015)	[2016] ZASCA 142; 2017 1 SA 572; [2016] 4 All SA 793	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	29 Sep 2016	SAFLII		4
Nova Property Group Holdings Ltd v Cobbett	[2016] ZASCA 63; 2016 4 SA 317; [2016] 3 All SA 32	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	12 May 2016	SAFLII		41

Law Journal Articles Referring to this Case

Journal Article Title	Citation(s)	Author	Jurisdiction	Date †	Full Text		Citation Index
Attacks on the Judiciary: Undercurrents of a Political versus Legal Constitutionalism Dilemma? (Vol 21)	[2018] PER 24	Potchefstroom Electronic Law Journal	South Africa	circa 2018	SAFLII
"The Prosecutor v Omar Hassan Ahmad Al - Bashir, International Criminal Court, July 2017" (Vol 1)	[2018] DEJURE 12	Swanepoel, C	South Africa	circa 2018	SAFLII

Cases and Articles Cited

Case Name	Citation(s)	Court	Jurisdiction	Date †	Full Text		Citation Index
City of Tshwane Metropolitan Municipality v Nambiti Technologies (Pty) Ltd	[2015] ZASCA 167; 2016 2 SA 494; [2016] 1 All SA 332	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	26 Nov 2015	SAFLII		31
Implications of President Al-Bashir's Visit to South Africa for International and Domestic Law'	(2015) 13 Journal of International Criminal Justice 1049	Journal of International Criminal Justice	United Kingdom	circa 2015	HeinOnline / LexisNexis		1
Southern Africa Litigation Centre v Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development & others	2015 5 SA 1		South Africa	circa 2015	LexisNexis		7
"The Duty on South Africa to Arrest and Surrender Al-Bashir under South African and International Law; Attempting to make a Collage from an Incoherent Framework"	(2015) 13 Journal of International Criminal Justice 1027	Journal of International Criminal Justice	United Kingdom	circa 2015	HeinOnline / LexisNexis		1
"Jus Cogens and Sovereign Immunity: Reconciling Divergence in Contemporary Jurisprudence"	(2015) 46 Georgetown Journal of International Law 1151	Georgetown Journal of International Law	United States	circa 2015	HeinOnline / LexisNexis		1
National Commissioner of the South African Police Service v Southern African Litigation Centre	[2014] ZACC 30; 2015 1 SA 315; 2015 1 SACR 255	Constitutional Court of South Africa	South Africa	30 Oct 2014	SAFLII		18
Minister of Defence and Military Veterans v Motau	[2014] ZACC 18; 2014 5 SA 69	Constitutional Court of South Africa	South Africa	10 Jun 2014	SAFLII		118
Fischer v Ramahlele	[2014] ZASCA 88; 2014 4 SA 614; [2014] 3 All SA 395	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	4 Jun 2014	SAFLII		122
MEC for Health, Eastern Cape v Kirland Investments (Pty) Ltd	[2014] ZACC 6; 2014 3 SA 481	Constitutional Court of South Africa	South Africa	25 Mar 2014	SAFLII		234
Bothma-Batho Transport (Edms) Bpk v S Bothma & Seun Transport (Edms) Bpk	[2013] ZASCA 176; 2014 2 SA 494; [2014] 1 All SA 517	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	28 Nov 2013	SAFLII		348
"Al-Bashir & the ICC: The Problem of Head of State Immunity"	(2013) 12 Chinese Journal of International Law 467	Chinese Journal of International Law	China	circa 2013	Westlaw		1
Qoboshiyane NO v Avusa Publishing Eastern Cape (Pty) Ltd	[2012] ZASCA 166; 2013 3 SA 315	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	21 Nov 2012	SAFLII		61
Children's Institute v Presiding Officer of the Children's Court, District of Krugersdorp (CCT 69/12)	[2012] ZACC 25; 2013 2 SA 620	Constitutional Court of South Africa	South Africa	9 Oct 2012	SAFLII		22
Germany v Italy: Greece intervening - Jurisdictional Immunities of the State - Judgment of 3 February 2012 - Judgment	[2012] ICJ 10	International Court of Justice	International	3 Feb 2012	WorldLII		1
"The Effect of Security Council Resolutions and Domestic Proceedings on State Obligations to Cooperate with the ICC"	(2012) 10 Journal of International Criminal Justice 299	Journal of International Criminal Justice	United Kingdom	circa 2012	HeinOnline / LexisNexis		1
Natal Joint Municipal Pension Fund v Endumeni Municipality	[2012] ZASCA 13; 2012 4 SA 593	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	circa 2012	SAFLII		321
"Problems Surrounding Arrest Warrants issued by the International Criminal Court: A Decade of Judicial Practice"	(2012) 32 Polish Yearbook of International Law 209	Polish Yearbook of International Law	Poland	circa 2012			1
Glenister v President of the Republic of South Africa & others	[2011] ZACC 6; 2011 3 SA 347	Constitutional Court of South Africa	South Africa	17 Mar 2011	SAFLII		111
Koyabe v Minister for Home Affairs	[2009] ZACC 23; 2010 4 SA 327	Constitutional Court of South Africa	South Africa	25 Aug 2009	SAFLII		118
"Does President Al Bashir Enjoy Immunity from Arrest?"	(2009) 7 Journal of International Criminal Justice 315	Journal of International Criminal Justice	United Kingdom	circa 2009	HeinOnline / LexisNexis		1
"s Immunities"	(2009) 7 Journal of International Criminal Justice 333	Journal of International Criminal Justice	United Kingdom	circa 2009	HeinOnline / LexisNexis		2
CUSA v Tao Ying Metal Industries	[2008] ZACC 15	Constitutional Court of South Africa	South Africa	18 Sep 2008	SAFLII		57
Djibouti v France - Certain Questions of Mutual Assistance in Criminal Matters - Judgment of 4 June 2008 - Judgments	[2008] ICJ 4	International Court of Justice	International	4 Jun 2008	WorldLII		1
"South Africa's Implementation of the Icc Statute: An African Example"	(2007) 5 Journal of International Criminal Justice 460	Journal of International Criminal Justice	United Kingdom	circa 2007	HeinOnline / LexisNexis		1
Charter plc v City Index Ltd	[2006] UKHL 26; [2007] 1 AC 270; [2007] 1 All ER 1049; [2007] 1 WLR 26; [2006] All ER (D) 145; [2006] 2 All ER (Comm) 951	House of Lords	United Kingdom	12 Oct 2006	BAILII		109
Ex parte Institute for Security Studies: In re S v Basson (CCT30/2003)	[2005] ZACC 4; 2006 6 SA 195	Constitutional Court of South Africa	South Africa	circa 2006	SAFLII		3
Oudekraal Estates (Pty) Ltd v City of Cape Town	[2004] ZASCA 48; 2004 6 SA 222; [2004] 3 All SA 1	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	28 May 2004	SAFLII		639
"The Surrender of War Criminals to the International Criminal Court"	(2003) 25 Loyola of Los Angeles International and Comparative Law Review 605	Loyola of Los Angeles International and Comparative Law Review	United States	circa 2003	HeinOnline		2
Democratic Republic of the Congo v Belgium - Arrest Warrant of 11 April 2000 - Judgment of 14 February 2002 - Judgments	[2002] ICJ 1	International Court of Justice	International	14 Feb 2002	WorldLII		1
"Public International Law"	2002 Annual Survey of South African Law 140	Annual Survey of South African Law	South Africa	circa 2002	HeinOnline		1
Sasol Synthetic Fuels (Pty) Ltd v Lambert	[2001] ZASCA 133; 2002 2 SA 21	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	27 Nov 2001	SAFLII		10
Al-Adsani v United Kingdom	[2001] ECHR 761; (2001) 12 BHRC 88; (2001) 34 EHRR 11; 123 ILR 24	European Court of Human Rights	Europe	21 Nov 2001	BAILII		45
Janse van Rensburg v Minister of Trade and Industry (CCT13/99)	[2000] ZACC 18; 2001 1 SA 29	Constitutional Court of South Africa	South Africa	29 Sep 2000	SAFLII		44
Mthembu v Letsela	[2000] ZASCA 181; 2000 3 SA 867; [2000] 3 All SA 219	Supreme Court of Appeal of South Africa	South Africa	30 May 2000	SAFLII		14
President of the Ordinary Court Martial v Freedom of Expression Institute (CCT5/99)	[1999] ZACC 10; 1999 4 SA 682	Constitutional Court of South Africa	South Africa	24 Aug 1999	SAFLII		43
R v Bow Street Magistrate; Ex parte Pinochet Ugarte (No 3)	[1999] UKHL 17; [2000] 1 AC 147; [1999] 2 All ER 97; [1999] 2 WLR 827; 119 ILR 135	House of Lords	United Kingdom	24 Mar 1999	BAILII		178
Bartle and the Commissioner of Police for the Metropolis , Ex Parte Pinochet, R v	[1998] UKHL 41; [1998] 4 All ER 897; [1998] 3 WLR 1456; (1998) 5 BHRC 209	House of Lords	United Kingdom	25 Nov 1998	BAILII		25
JT Publishing (Pty) Ltd v Minister of Safety and Security	[1996] ZACC 23; 1997 3 SA 514	Constitutional Court of South Africa	South Africa	21 Nov 1996	SAFLII		93
Government of the Republic of South Africa v Government of KwaZulu	1983 1 SA 164		South Africa	circa 1983	LexisNexis		13
South Atlantic Islands Development Corporation Ltd v Buchan	1971 1 SA 234		South Africa	circa 1971	LexisNexis		13
Wendywood Development (Pty) Ltd v Rieger	1971 3 SA 28		South Africa	circa 1971	LexisNexis		9
Van Rensburg v Van Rensburg en Andere	1963 1 SA 505		South Africa	circa 1963	LexisNexis		35
Springs Town Council v Soonah	1963 1 SA 659		South Africa	circa 1963	LexisNexis		3
R v Tucker	1953 3 SA 150		South Africa	circa 1953	LexisNexis		6
Durban Corporation v Rex	1946 NPD 109		South Africa - Natal	circa 1946			4
Kent NO v South African Railways	[1946] AD 398			circa 1946			25
Cristina	[1938] AC 485; [1938] 1 All ER 719		United Kingdom	circa 1938	LexisNexis / Westlaw		98
New Modderfontein Gold Mining Co v Transvaal Provincial Administration	[1919] AD 367			circa 1919			22
Middelburg Municipality v Gertzen	[1914] AD 544			circa 1914			9
Tachiona v Mugabe	169 FSupp 2d 259		United States	circa 1998	Westlaw		4
Kalogeropoulou v Greece and Germany	129 ILR 537			circa 1998			4