Special Reference No 1 of 1964 v 74

[1964] INSC 209; [1965] 1 SCR 413; AIR 1965 SC 745

Supreme Court of India

India

30th September, 1964

Cases Referring to this Case

Case Name	Citation(s)	Court †	Jurisdiction	Date	Full Text	Citation Index
Maan Pal Singh v UP Thru' Chief Secry - WRIT - C	[2007] INAHHC 931	Allahbad High Court	India - Allahbad	15 Jan 2007	LIIofIndia
Ajeet Singh @ Muraha v Up & Others - Criminal Misc Writ Petition	[2006] INAHHC 10938	Allahbad High Court	India - Allahbad	5 Jul 2006	LIIofIndia
Nardev Singh & Others v Mahavir Singh & another - SECOND APPEAL	[2006] INAHHC 8432	Allahbad High Court	India - Allahbad	26 Apr 2006	LIIofIndia
Nardev Singh & Others v Mahavir Singh & a kl - SECOND APPEAL	[2006] INAHHC 8143	Allahbad High Court	India - Allahbad	21 Apr 2006	LIIofIndia
Anugrah Narain Singh v UP - WRIT - C	[2005] INAHHC 7979	Allahbad High Court	India - Allahbad	22 Dec 2005	LIIofIndia
Union Of India Thru' Secre Ministry Of Railways And Anr v CAT , Allahabad, - WRIT - A	[2005] INAHHC 6223	Allahbad High Court	India - Allahbad	22 Nov 2005	LIIofIndia
Naresh Chandra v Opsmalik & Others - Contempt Application (Civil)	[2004] INAHHC 40	Allahbad High Court	India - Allahbad	27 Jan 2004	LIIofIndia
Minister of Police v Moala	[1997] TOCA 1	Court of Appeal of Tonga	Tonga	29 Jun 1997	PacLII	3
District BC Mahila Welfare Associat v Sri Samuel - CANo 692 of 2006	[2006] INAPHC 420	High Court of Andhra Pradesh	India - Andhra Pradesh	19 Jul 2006	LIIofIndia
Egan v Willis	[1998] HCA 71; (1998) 195 CLR 424; 158 ALR 527; 73 ALJR 75	High Court of Australia	Australia - Commonwealth	19 Nov 1998	AustLII	173
Bhowanipur Gujarati Education Society & Anr v The Kolkata Municipal Corporation - WP	[2007] INWBKOHC 1342	High Court of Calcutta	India	5 Oct 2007	LIIofIndia
Atul Kumar Rai v M/S Koshika Telecom Ltd - Contapp (C) 6/2012	[2012] INDLHC 2500	High Court of Delhi	India	17 Apr 2012	LIIofIndia
Manohar Lal Sharma v Union of India and Anr - WP (C) 6355/2011	[2011] INDLHC 4238	High Court of Delhi	India	1 Sep 2011	LIIofIndia
Suresh Kalmadi v Union of India - Lpa 707/2011	[2011] INDLHC 4208	High Court of Delhi	India	30 Aug 2011	LIIofIndia
Nehru Memorial Museum & Library Society v DR N Balakrishnan - Ccpco 380/2010	[2010] INDLHC 5152	High Court of Delhi	India	25 Oct 2010	LIIofIndia
Maan Pal Singh v UP Thru' Chief Secry - WRIT - C	[2007] INUPHC 931	High Court of Judicature at Allahabad	India	15 Jan 2007	LIIofIndia
Ajeet Singh @ Muraha v Up & Others - Criminal Misc Writ Petition	[2006] INUPHC 10938	High Court of Judicature at Allahabad	India	5 Jul 2006	LIIofIndia
Nardev Singh & Others v Mahavir Singh & another - SECOND APPEAL	[2006] INUPHC 8432	High Court of Judicature at Allahabad	India	26 Apr 2006	LIIofIndia
Nardev Singh & Others v Mahavir Singh & a kl - SECOND APPEAL	[2006] INUPHC 8143	High Court of Judicature at Allahabad	India	21 Apr 2006	LIIofIndia
Anugrah Narain Singh v UP - WRIT - C	[2005] INUPHC 7979	High Court of Judicature at Allahabad	India	22 Dec 2005	LIIofIndia
Union Of India Thru' Secre Ministry Of Railways And Anr v CAT , Allahabad, - WRIT - A	[2005] INUPHC 6223	High Court of Judicature at Allahabad	India	22 Nov 2005	LIIofIndia
Naresh Chandra v Opsmalik & Others - Contempt Application (Civil)	[2004] INUPHC 40	High Court of Judicature at Allahabad	India	27 Jan 2004	LIIofIndia
Contpetition Against Jagmohan Parashar v - Cont--2/2007	[2007] INMPHC 213	High Court of Madhya Pradesh	India - Madhya Pradesh	13 Mar 2007	LIIofIndia
Municipal Corporation of GR Mumbai v Ankita Sinha	[2021] INSC 583	Supreme Court of India	India	7 Oct 2021	LIIofIndia
Ajit Mohan v Legislative Assembly, National Capital Territory of Delhi	[2021] INSC 300	Supreme Court of India	India	8 Jul 2021	LIIofIndia
Keisham Meghachandra Singh v the Honble Speaker Manipur Legislative Assembly	[2020] INSC 59	Supreme Court of India	India	21 Jan 2020	LIIofIndia
Tamil Nadu Polution Control Board v Sterlite Industries (i) Ltd	[2019] INSC 202	Supreme Court of India	India	18 Feb 2019	LIIofIndia
Asian Resurfacing of Road Agency P Ltd v Central Bureau of Investigation	[2018] INSC 259	Supreme Court of India	India	28 Mar 2018	LIIofIndia
Justice (Retd) Markandey Katju v the Lok Sabha & Anr	[2016] INSC 888	Supreme Court of India	India	15 Dec 2016	LIIofIndia
Jindal Stainless Ltd & Anr v Haryana	[2016] INSC 785	Supreme Court of India	India	11 Nov 2016	LIIofIndia
Nabam Rebia and Etc Etc v Deputy Speaker	[2016] INSC 496	Supreme Court of India	India	13 Jul 2016	LIIofIndia
Alagaapuram R Mohanraj v Tamil Nadu Legislative Assembly Rep by Its Secretary and Anr	[2016] INSC 143	Supreme Court of India	India	12 Feb 2016	LIIofIndia
Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association and Anr v Union of India	[2015] INSC 776	Supreme Court of India	India	16 Oct 2015	LIIofIndia
Union of India v Major General Shri Kant Sharma & Anr	[2015] INSC 201	Supreme Court of India	India	11 Mar 2015	LIIofIndia
Balinga Reddy Etcetc v Karnataka State Transport Auth	[2014] INSC 920	Supreme Court of India	India	18 Dec 2014	LIIofIndia
Madras Bar Association v Union of India & Anr	[2014] INSC 717	Supreme Court of India	India	25 Sep 2014	LIIofIndia
Subrata Roy Sahara v Uoi	[2014] INSC 398	Supreme Court of India	India	6 May 2014	LIIofIndia
Tcgupta & Anr v Hari Om Prakash	[2013] INSC 961	Supreme Court of India	India	8 Oct 2013	LIIofIndia
Of Constitution v of India	[2012] INSC 559	Supreme Court of India	India	27 Sep 2012	LIIofIndia
Namit Sharma v Union of India	[2012] INSC 526	Supreme Court of India	India	13 Sep 2012	LIIofIndia
Bhim Singh v Uoi	[2010] INSC 358	Supreme Court of India	India	6 May 2010	LIIofIndia
Amrinder Singh v Splcommittee,punjab Vidhan Sabha	[2010] INSC 533	Supreme Court of India	India	26 Apr 2010	LIIofIndia
Ramdas Athawale v Union of India	[2010] INSC 235	Supreme Court of India	India	29 Mar 2010	LIIofIndia
West Bengal v Commttfor Protect,democratic Rights	[2010] INSC 136	Supreme Court of India	India	17 Feb 2010	LIIofIndia
All Bengal Excise Licensees Association v Raghabendra Singh	[2007] INSC 264	Supreme Court of India	India	9 Mar 2007	LIIofIndia
Raja Ram Pal v Speaker, Lok Sabha	[2007] INSC 24	Supreme Court of India	India	10 Jan 2007	LIIofIndia
Raja Ram Pal v the Hon'Ble Speaker, Lok Sabha	[2007] INSC 23	Supreme Court of India	India	10 Jan 2007	LIIofIndia
Kuldip Nayar v Union of India	[2006] INSC 512	Supreme Court of India	India	22 Aug 2006	LIIofIndia
DR Mahachandra Prasad Singh v Chairman, Bihar Legislative Council	[2004] INSC 659	Supreme Court of India	India	27 Oct 2004	LIIofIndia
Special Reference Case 1 of 2002	[2002] INSC 445	Supreme Court of India	India	28 Oct 2002	LIIofIndia
SR Bommai v Union of India	[1994] INSC 173; (1994) 3 SCC 1; [1994] 2 SCR 644; 1994 2 SCALE 37; 1994 2 JT 215; AIR 1994 SC 1918	Supreme Court of India	India	11 Mar 1994	LIIofIndia	83
Ravi S Naik v Union of India	[1994] INSC 102; 1994 1 SCALE 487; 1994 1 JT 551; 1994 2 SCC Supl 641; 1994 1 SCR 754; AIR 1994 SC 1558	Supreme Court of India	India	9 Feb 1994	LIIofIndia	24
Kihoto Hollohan v Zachillhu	[1992] INSC 53; 1992 1 SCALE 338; 1992 1 JT 600; 1992 2 SCC Supl 651; 1992 1 SCR 686	Supreme Court of India	India	18 Feb 1992	LIIofIndia	1
Delhi Judicial Service Association Tis Hazari Court, Delhi v Gujarat	[1991] INSC 229; (1991) 4 SCC 406; 1991 2 SCALE 501; 1991 3 JT 617; 1991 3 SCR 936; AIR 1991 SC 2176	Supreme Court of India	India	11 Sep 1991	LIIofIndia	30
SMD Kiran Pasha v Government of Andhra Pradesh	[1989] INSC 339; 1989 2 SCALE 1083; 1989 4 JT 366; 1990 1 SCC 328; 1989 2 SCR Supl 105	Supreme Court of India	India	9 Nov 1989	LIIofIndia	5
Kehar Singh & Anr v Union of India & Anr	[1988] INSC 370; (1989) 1 SCC 204; [1989] SCC (Cri) 86; 1988 2 SCALE 1565; 1988 4 JT 693; 1988 3 SCR Supl 1102; AIR 1989 SC 653	Supreme Court of India	India	16 Dec 1988	LIIofIndia	23
PN Duda v v P Shiv Shankar	[1988] INSC 106; (1988) 3 SCC 167; 1988 1 SCALE 728; 1988 2 JT 102; 1988 3 SCR 547; AIR 1988 SC 1208	Supreme Court of India	India	15 Apr 1988	LIIofIndia
PN Duda v v P Shiv Shankar	[1988] INSC 106; (1988) 3 SCC 167; 1988 1 SCALE 728; 1988 2 JT 102; 1988 3 SCR 547; AIR 1988 SC 1208	Supreme Court of India	India	15 Apr 1988	LIIofIndia	19
R S Nayak v a R Antulay	[1984] INSC 34; AIR 1984 SC 684; 1984 1 SCALE 198; 1984 2 SCR 495	Supreme Court of India	India	16 Feb 1984	LIIofIndia	18
In Re the Special Courts Bill, 1978 v	[1978] INSC 247	Supreme Court of India	India	1 Dec 1978	LIIofIndia
Karnataka v Union of India & Anr	[1977] INSC 213; (1977) 4 SCC 608; (1978) 2 SCR 1; AIR 1978 SC 68	Supreme Court of India	India	8 Nov 1977	LIIofIndia	27
Baradakanta Mishra v the Registrar of Orissa High Court & Anr	[1973] INSC 210; (1974) 1 SCC 374; [1974] 2 SCR 282; AIR 1974 SC 710	Supreme Court of India	India	19 Nov 1973	LIIofIndia	19
Kesavananda Bharati Sripadagalvaru v Kerala and Anr	[1973] INSC 258	Supreme Court of India	India	24 Apr 1973	LIIofIndia
C K Daphtary v o P Gupta	[1971] INSC 87; 1971 1 SCC 626; [1971] SCR 76; AIR 1971 SC 1132	Supreme Court of India	India	19 Mar 1971	LIIofIndia	12
Tej Kiran Jain v N Sanjiva Reddy	[1970] INSC 137; (1970) 2 SCC 272; 1971 1 SCR 612; AIR 1970 SC 1573	Supreme Court of India	India	8 May 1970	LIIofIndia	1
Ratilal Bhanji Mithani v Asstt Collector of Customs, Bombay & Anr	[1967] INSC 141; 1967 3 SCR 926; AIR 1967 SC 1639	Supreme Court of India	India	4 May 1967	LIIofIndia	3
Naresh Shridhar Mirajkar v Maharashtra & Anr	[1966] INSC 64; [1966] 3 SCR 744; AIR 1967 SC 1	Supreme Court of India	India	3 Mar 1966	LIIofIndia	70
Chhotabhai Jethabhai Patel and Co v the Union of India & Anr	[1961] INSC 350; 1962 2 SCR Supl 1; AIR 1962 SC 1006	Supreme Court of India	India	11 Dec 1961	LIIofIndia	14
Kishwar Jahan v West Bengal - WP	[2011] INWBKOHCA 15916		India	18 Mar 2011	LIIofIndia
Baz Muhammad Kakar v Federation of Pakistan	[2012] PKSC 58		Pakistan	15 Sep 2012	CommonLII
S v Mokgiba	2020 1 SACR 534		South Africa	22 Jul 2019	SAFLII
Minister of Police v Moala	[1997] Tonga LR 210		Tonga	20 Jun 1997	PacLII	6
Reference by the President of Islamic Republic of Pakistan Under Article 186 of the Constituion of Pakistan regarding Elections for the Members of the Senate of Pakistan v	[2021] PKSC 242		Pakistan	17 Aug 2021	CommonLII

Law Reform Reports Referring to this Case

Journal Article Title	Citation(s)	Author †	Jurisdiction	Date	Full Text		Citation Index
- The Judges (Inquiry) Bill, 2005 (Report No 195)	[2006] INLC 1	Law Commission of India Reports	India	circa 2006	LIIofIndia

Legislation Cited

Legislation Name	Provision
Constitution

Cases and Articles Cited

Case Name	Citation(s)	Court †	Jurisdiction	Date	Full Text	Citation Index
Ravi S Naik v Union of India	[1994] INSC 102; 1994 1 SCALE 487; 1994 1 JT 551; 1994 2 SCC Supl 641; 1994 1 SCR 754; AIR 1994 SC 1558	Supreme Court of India	India	9 Feb 1994	LIIofIndia	24
Kihoto Hollohan v Zachillhu	[1992] INSC 53; 1992 1 SCALE 338; 1992 1 JT 600; 1992 2 SCC Supl 651; 1992 1 SCR 686	Supreme Court of India	India	18 Feb 1992	LIIofIndia	1
Delhi Judicial Service Association Tis Hazari Court, Delhi v Gujarat	[1991] INSC 229; (1991) 4 SCC 406; 1991 2 SCALE 501; 1991 3 JT 617; 1991 3 SCR 936; AIR 1991 SC 2176	Supreme Court of India	India	11 Sep 1991	LIIofIndia	30
SMD Kiran Pasha v Government of Andhra Pradesh	[1989] INSC 339; 1989 2 SCALE 1083; 1989 4 JT 366; 1990 1 SCC 328; 1989 2 SCR Supl 105	Supreme Court of India	India	9 Nov 1989	LIIofIndia	5
Kehar Singh & Anr v Union of India & Anr	[1988] INSC 370; (1989) 1 SCC 204; [1989] SCC (Cri) 86; 1988 2 SCALE 1565; 1988 4 JT 693; 1988 3 SCR Supl 1102; AIR 1989 SC 653	Supreme Court of India	India	16 Dec 1988	LIIofIndia	23
PN Duda v v P Shiv Shankar	[1988] INSC 106; (1988) 3 SCC 167; 1988 1 SCALE 728; 1988 2 JT 102; 1988 3 SCR 547; AIR 1988 SC 1208	Supreme Court of India	India	15 Apr 1988	LIIofIndia	19
PN Duda v v P Shiv Shankar	[1988] INSC 106; (1988) 3 SCC 167; 1988 1 SCALE 728; 1988 2 JT 102; 1988 3 SCR 547; AIR 1988 SC 1208	Supreme Court of India	India	15 Apr 1988	LIIofIndia
R S Nayak v a R Antulay	[1984] INSC 34; AIR 1984 SC 684; 1984 1 SCALE 198; 1984 2 SCR 495	Supreme Court of India	India	16 Feb 1984	LIIofIndia	18
In Re the Special Courts Bill, 1978 v	[1978] INSC 247	Supreme Court of India	India	1 Dec 1978	LIIofIndia
Karnataka v Union of India & Anr	[1977] INSC 213; (1977) 4 SCC 608; (1978) 2 SCR 1; AIR 1978 SC 68	Supreme Court of India	India	8 Nov 1977	LIIofIndia	27
Baradakanta Mishra v the Registrar of Orissa High Court & Anr	[1973] INSC 210; (1974) 1 SCC 374; [1974] 2 SCR 282; AIR 1974 SC 710	Supreme Court of India	India	19 Nov 1973	LIIofIndia	19
Kesavananda Bharati Sripadagalvaru v Kerala and Anr	[1973] INSC 258	Supreme Court of India	India	24 Apr 1973	LIIofIndia
C K Daphtary v o P Gupta	[1971] INSC 87; 1971 1 SCC 626; [1971] SCR 76; AIR 1971 SC 1132	Supreme Court of India	India	19 Mar 1971	LIIofIndia	12
Tej Kiran Jain v N Sanjiva Reddy	[1970] INSC 137; (1970) 2 SCC 272; 1971 1 SCR 612; AIR 1970 SC 1573	Supreme Court of India	India	8 May 1970	LIIofIndia	1
Ratilal Bhanji Mithani v Asstt Collector of Customs, Bombay & Anr	[1967] INSC 141; 1967 3 SCR 926; AIR 1967 SC 1639	Supreme Court of India	India	4 May 1967	LIIofIndia	3
Naresh Shridhar Mirajkar v Maharashtra & Anr	[1966] INSC 64; [1966] 3 SCR 744; AIR 1967 SC 1	Supreme Court of India	India	3 Mar 1966	LIIofIndia	70
In re Sea Customs Act s 20(2)	[1963] INSC 156; [1964] 3 SCR 787; AIR 1963 SC 1760	Supreme Court of India	India	10 May 1963	LIIofIndia	22
Chhotabhai Jethabhai Patel and Co v the Union of India & Anr	[1961] INSC 350; 1962 2 SCR Supl 1; AIR 1962 SC 1006	Supreme Court of India	India	11 Dec 1961	LIIofIndia	14
Re Berubari Union of India	[1960] 3 SCR 250; AIR 1960 SC 845	Supreme Court of India	India	circa 1960		16
Re Kerala Education Bill	[1959] SCR 995; AIR 1958 SC 956	Supreme Court of India	India	circa 1958		69
U P v Manbodhan Lal Srivastava	[1957] INSC 75; [1958] SCR 533; AIR 1957 SC 912	Supreme Court of India	India	20 Sep 1957	LIIofIndia	44
Nafisul Hasaan and UP	AIR 1954 SC 636	Supreme Court of India	India	circa 1954		8
Re: the Delhi Laws ACT, 1912, the Ajmer-Merwara	[1951] INSC 35; [1951] SCR 747; AIR 1951 SC 332	Supreme Court of India	India	23 May 1951	LIIofIndia	68
[1979] SC 478	[1979] SC 478		United Kingdom - Scotland	circa 1979		28
51 RF 1992	51 RF 1992		Brazil	circa 1992		1
320 RF 1992	320 RF 1992		Brazil	circa 1992		1
Bradlaugh v Gossett	[1884] UKLawRpKQB 20; (1884) 12 QBD 271; 50 LT 620; 53 LJQB 209; 32 WR 552		United Kingdom	9 Feb 1884	CommonLII	119
2 Er 11	2 ER 11		United Kingdom	circa 1991	CommonLII	1
[1989] SC 653	[1989] SC 653		United Kingdom - Scotland	circa 1989		8
16 Er 792	16 ER 792		United Kingdom	circa 1991	CommonLII	1
[1978] SC 68	[1978] SC 68		United Kingdom - Scotland	circa 1978		19
R v the Earl of Crewe, Ex parte Sekgome	[1910] UKLawRpKQB 78; [1910] 2 KB 576		United Kingdom	2 May 1910	CommonLII	26
Fielding v Thomas	[1896] UKLawRpAC 47; [1896] AC 600		United Kingdom	28 Jul 1896	CommonLII	19
112 Er 11	112 ER 11		United Kingdom	circa 1991	CommonLII	1
[1952] SCR 28	[1952] SCR 28			circa 1952		10
101 RF 1984	101 RF 1984		Brazil	circa 1984		1
Howard v Sir William Gosset	[1845] EngR 817; (1845) 10 QB 359; 116 ER 139		United Kingdom	circa 1845	CommonLII	7
1 SCR 806	1 SCR 806			circa 1991		16
(1874) 10 QB 359	(1874) 10 QB 359		United Kingdom	circa 1874	LexisNexis / Westlaw	1
86 Er 792	86 ER 792		United Kingdom	circa 1991	CommonLII	2
Reference by the President of Islamic Republic of Pakistan Under Article 186 of the Constituion of Pakistan regarding Elections for the Members of the Senate of Pakistan v	[2021] PKSC 242		Pakistan	17 Aug 2021	CommonLII
Anantha Krishnan v Madras	AIR 1952 Mad 395		India - Tamil Nadu	circa 1952		3
Minister of Police v Moala	[1997] Tonga LR 210		Tonga	20 Jun 1997	PacLII	6
Fielding v Thomas	[1896] AC 660		United Kingdom	circa 1896	LexisNexis / Westlaw	1
Secretary of State for Home Affairs v O'Brien	[1923] AC 603; [1923] 2 KB 361		United Kingdom	circa 1923	LexisNexis / Westlaw	111
[1896] RAC 600	[1896] RAC 600		Canada - Quebec	circa 1896		1
S v Mokgiba	2020 1 SACR 534		South Africa	22 Jul 2019	SAFLII
Jay and Topham's Case	12 St Tr 822		United Kingdom	circa 2019		4
Baz Muhammad Kakar v Federation of Pakistan	[2012] PKSC 58		Pakistan	15 Sep 2012	CommonLII
[1978] SC 727	[1978] SC 727		United Kingdom - Scotland	circa 1978		9
Stockdale v Hansard	112 ER 1112		United Kingdom	circa 2012	CommonLII	28
95 Er 005	95 ER 005		United Kingdom	circa 2012	CommonLII	1
Kishwar Jahan v West Bengal - WP	[2011] INWBKOHCA 15916		India	18 Mar 2011	LIIofIndia
Stockdale v Hansard	12 ER 1112		United Kingdom	circa 2011	CommonLII	1
Burdett (Bart),-Plaintiff (in Error); Abbot (Speaker, H C),-Defendant (in Error): and Burdett (Bart),-Plaintiff (in Error); Colman (Sergeant at Arms),-Defendant (in Error)	[1817] EngR 614; 3 ER 1289; (1817) 5 Dowl 165		United Kingdom	circa 1817	CommonLII	9
[1974] SC 710	[1974] SC 710		United Kingdom - Scotland	circa 1974		7

LawCite: Privacy | Disclaimers | Conditions of Use | Acknowledgements | Feedback