THOMAS CLINE; TIMOTHY IRVING; KEITH RINEY; DENNIS TRAMMELL each on his own behalf and on behalf of all the employees similarly situated, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v THE INDUSTRIAL MAINTENANCE ENGINEERING & CONTRACTING CO; GEORGE R BELTZ, individually and in his official capacity as International President of the IUPIW and as a fiduciary; PAMELA BARLOW, individually and in her official capacity as Secretary-Treasurer of the IUPIW and as a fiduciary; JOE BELTZ, individually and in his official capacity as Vice President of the IUPIW and as a fiduciary; THOMAS WALSH, individually and in his capacity as fiduciary; MAURICE LAMPLEY, individually and in his capacity as fiduciary; JOHN DELANEY, individually and in his capacity as a fiduciary; HAROLD JOHNSON, individually and in his capacity as a fiduciary; ROBERT ORTEGA, individually and in his capacity as a fiduciary; GEOFFREY BELTZ, individually and in his capacity as a fiduciary; OAK TREE ADMINISTRATORS, INC; ERISA, regulated employee benefit plan; INTERNATIONAL UNION OF PETROLEUM & INDUSTRIAL WORKERS CANADIAN BENEFIT FUND; GREAT WEST LIFE AND ANNUITY CO , Defendants-Appellees THE INDUSTRIAL MAINTENANCE ENGINEERING & CONTRACTING CO; GEOFFREY BELTZ, individually and in his capacity as a fiduciary; OAK TREE ADMINISTRATORS, INC , ERISA, regulated employee benefit plan; GREAT WEST LIFE & ANNUITY CO , Defendants, and GEORGE R BELTZ, individually and in his official capacity as International President of the IUPIW and as a fiduciary; PAMELA BARLOW, individually and in her official capacity as Secretary-Treasurer of the IUPIW and as a fiduciary; JOE BELTZ, individually and in his official capacity as Vice President of the IUPIW and as a fiduciary; THOMAS WALSH, individually and in his capacity as fiduciary; MAURICE LAMPLEY, individually and in his capacity as fiduciary; JOHN DELANEY, individually and in his capacity as a fiduciary; HAROLD JOHNSON, individually and in his capacity as a fiduciary; ROBERT ORTEGA, individually an

200 F3d 1223

United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit

United States

11th January, 2000

Cases Referring to this Case

Case Name †	Citation(s)	Court	Jurisdiction	Date	Full Text	Citation Index
Honolulu Joint Apprenticeship and Training Committee of United Association Local Union No 675	332 F3d 1234	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	19 Jun 2003	WorldLII	5
Metzler Investment v Corinthian	[2008] USCA9 270	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	25 Jul 2008	WorldLII
Metzler Investment v Corinthian Colleges	[2008] USCA9 365	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	26 Aug 2008	WorldLII
Nissan Fire & Marine Insurance Co, Ltd; Hitachi Data Systems Corporation ,plaintiffs-Appellants, v Fritz Companies, Inc; Tower Air, Inc ,defendants-Appellees	210 F3d 1099	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	25 Apr 2000	WorldLII	10
Orth, Ronald v WI State Employee	[2008] USCA7 682	United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit	United States	22 Oct 2008	WorldLII
Salovaara v Eckert	222 F3d 19	United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit	United States	9 Aug 2000	WorldLII	10
THOMAS CLINE; TIMOTHY IRVING; KEITH RINEY; DENNIS TRAMMELL each on his own behalf and on behalf of all the employees similarly situated, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v THE INDUSTRIAL MAINTENANCE ENGINEERING & CONTRACTING CO; GEORGE R BELTZ, individually and in his official capacity as International President of the IUPIW and as a fiduciary; PAMELA BARLOW, individually and in her official capacity as Secretary-Treasurer of the IUPIW and as a fiduciary; JOE BELTZ, individually and in his official capacity as Vice President of the IUPIW and as a fiduciary; THOMAS WALSH, individually and in his capacity as fiduciary; MAURICE LAMPLEY, individually and in his capacity as fiduciary; JOHN DELANEY, individually and in his capacity as a fiduciary; HAROLD JOHNSON, individually and in his capacity as a fiduciary; ROBERT ORTEGA, individually and in his capacity as a fiduciary; GEOFFREY BELTZ, individually and in his capacity as a fiduciary; OAK TREE ADMINISTRATORS, INC; ERISA, regulated employee benefit plan; INTERNATIONAL UNION OF PETROLEUM & INDUSTRIAL WORKERS CANADIAN BENEFIT FUND; GREAT WEST LIFE AND ANNUITY CO , Defendants-Appellees THE INDUSTRIAL MAINTENANCE ENGINEERING & CONTRACTING CO; GEOFFREY BELTZ, individually and in his capacity as a fiduciary; OAK TREE ADMINISTRATORS, INC , ERISA, regulated employee benefit plan; GREAT WEST LIFE & ANNUITY CO , Defendants, and GEORGE R BELTZ, individually and in his official capacity as International President of the IUPIW and as a fiduciary; PAMELA BARLOW, individually and in her official capacity as Secretary-Treasurer of the IUPIW and as a fiduciary; JOE BELTZ, individually and in his official capacity as Vice President of the IUPIW and as a fiduciary; THOMAS WALSH, individually and in his capacity as fiduciary; MAURICE LAMPLEY, individually and in his capacity as fiduciary; JOHN DELANEY, individually and in his capacity as a fiduciary; HAROLD JOHNSON, individually and in his capacity as a fiduciary; ROBERT ORTEGA, individually an		United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	11 Jan 2000	WorldLII
Trustees of the Southern California Bakery Drivers Security Fund	474 F3d 642	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	18 Jan 2007	WorldLII
Vaught v Scottsdale Healthcare	[2008] USCA9 416	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	29 Sep 2008	WorldLII

Cases and Articles Cited

Case Name †	Citation(s)	Court	Jurisdiction	Date	Full Text	Citation Index
Anderson v Liberty Lobby, Inc	477 US 242; 91 L Ed 2d 202; 106 SCt 2505; [1986] Adams 31	United States Supreme Court	United States	25 Jun 1986	WorldLII	6467
Celotex Corporation v Catrett	477 US 317; 91 L Ed 2d 265; 106 SCt 2548; 54 USLW 4775; [1986] Fuller 47	United States Supreme Court	United States	25 Jun 1986	WorldLII	5738
Cinelli v Security Pacific Corporation	61 F3d 1437	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	7 Aug 1995	WorldLII	8
Corder v Gates	104 F3d 247	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	27 Dec 1996	WorldLII	8
Corder v Howard Johnson & Co	53 F3d 225	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	31 Jan 1995	WorldLII	8
Credit Managers Association of Southern California v Kennesaw Life and Accident Insurance Co	25 F3d 743; 18 Employee Benefits Cas 1138	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	19 May 1994	WorldLII	7
Estate of Blas Chargualaf v Winkler Md	792 F2d 858; 6 Fed RServ3d 426	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	3 Jul 1986	WorldLII	16
Estate of Shockley v Alyeska Pipeline Service Co	130 F3d 403	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	24 Nov 1997	WorldLII	11
First National Bank of Arizona v Cities Service Co	391 US 253; 20 L Ed 2d 569; 88 SCt 1575	United States Supreme Court	United States	20 May 1968	WorldLII	445
Forsyth v Humana, Inc	114 F3d 1467; 119 SCt 710; 142 L Ed 2d 753	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	23 May 1997	WorldLII	56
Hummell v SE Rykoff & Co	634 F2d 446	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	22 Dec 1980	WorldLII	120
Hunt v Hawthorne Associates Inc	119 F3d 888	United States Court of Appeals, Eleventh Circuit	United States	5 Aug 1997	WorldLII	4
Jackson v EJ Brach Corporation	937 FSupp 735		United States	circa 1968	Westlaw	2
Kilgour v City of Pasadena	53 F3d 1007	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	24 Jul 1995	WorldLII	10
Levi Strauss & Co v Shilon	121 F3d 1309		United States		Westlaw	9
Lujan v National Wildlife Federation	497 US 871; 111 L Ed 2d 695; 110 SCt 3177	United States Supreme Court	United States	27 Jun 1990	WorldLII	287
Moran v Aetna Life Ins Co	872 F2d 296		United States	circa 1990	Westlaw	22
Oregon Short Line Railroad Co v Department of Revenue Oregon	139 F3d 1259	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	23 Mar 1998	WorldLII	7
Prof'l Helicopter Pilots Ass'n v Denison	804 FSupp 1447		United States	circa 1998	Westlaw	2
Russell v Rolfs	893 F2d 1033	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	9 Jan 1990	WorldLII	54
Sablan v Department of Finance	856 F2d 1317	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	2 Sep 1988	WorldLII	55
Smith v Hughes Aircraft Co	22 F3d 1432	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	3 May 1994	WorldLII	26
Tarin v County of Los Angeles	123 F3d 1259	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	27 Aug 1997	WorldLII	9
Terrell v Brewer	935 F2d 1015	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	5 Jun 1991	WorldLII	100
Thomas v Farley	31 F3d 557	United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit	United States	4 Aug 1994	WorldLII	18
United Mine Workers v Powhatan Fuel, Inc	828 F2d 710		United States	circa 1998	Westlaw	10
United States v Blodgett	709 F2d 608	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	1 Jul 1983	WorldLII	33
Varity Corporation v Howe	516 US 489; 134 L Ed 2d 130; 116 SCt 1065	United States Supreme Court	United States	19 Mar 1996	WorldLII	190
7 Equal Opportunities Law Review 193	7 Equal Opportunities Law Review 193	Equal Opportunities Law Review	United Kingdom	circa 1998		1
29 USC S1001	29 USC S1001	United States Code	United States	circa 1998	LII (Cornell)	1
200 f3d 1223			United States	circa 1998	Westlaw	9

LawCite: Privacy | Disclaimers | Conditions of Use | Acknowledgements | Feedback