AT & t Communications, Plaintiff - Appellant v Bellsouth Telecommunications Inc; Louisiana Public Service Commission; Don Owen; Irma Muse Dixon; Dale Sittig; James M Field; Jack a Blossman; Commissioner of Louisiana Public Service Commission, in their official capacities, Defendants - Appellees AT & t Communications of the South Central States, Inc, also known as AT & t, Plaintiff - Appellant, v Bellsouth Telecommunications Inc; Louisiana Public Service Commission; Don Owen, the Commissioners of the Louisiana Public Service Commissioners in their Official Capacity; Irma Muse Dixon, the Commissioners of the Louisiana Public Service Commissioners in their Official Capacity; Dale Sittig, the Commissioners of the Louisiana Public Service Commissioners in their Official Capacity; James M Field, the Commissioners of the Louisiana Public Service Commissioners in their Official Capacity; Jack a Blossman JR, the Commissioners of the Louisiana Public Service Commissioners in their Official Capacity, Defendants - Appellees American Communication Services of Louisiana, Inc; American Communication Services of Baton Rouge, Inc; American Communication Services of Shreveport, Inc, Plaintiffs - Appellants, v Bellsouth Telecommunications Inc; the Louisiana Public Service Commission; Don Owen; Irma Muse Dixon; Dale Sittig; James M Field; Jack a Blossman also known as Jay Blossom; Commissioners of the Louisiana Public Service Commission, in their official capacities, Defendants - Appellees

238 F3d 636

United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit

United States

16th January, 2001

Cases Referring to this Case

Case Name †	Citation(s)	Court	Jurisdiction	Date	Full Text	Citation Index
AT & t Communications, Plaintiff - Appellant v Bellsouth Telecommunications Inc; Louisiana Public Service Commission; Don Owen; Irma Muse Dixon; Dale Sittig; James M Field; Jack a Blossman; Commissioner of Louisiana Public Service Commission, in their official capacities, Defendants - Appellees AT & t Communications of the South Central States, Inc, also known as AT & t, Plaintiff - Appellant, v Bellsouth Telecommunications Inc; Louisiana Public Service Commission; Don Owen, the Commissioners of the Louisiana Public Service Commissioners in their Official Capacity; Irma Muse Dixon, the Commissioners of the Louisiana Public Service Commissioners in their Official Capacity; Dale Sittig, the Commissioners of the Louisiana Public Service Commissioners in their Official Capacity; James M Field, the Commissioners of the Louisiana Public Service Commissioners in their Official Capacity; Jack a Blossman JR, the Commissioners of the Louisiana Public Service Commissioners in their Official Capacity, Defendants - Appellees American Communication Services of Louisiana, Inc; American Communication Services of Baton Rouge, Inc; American Communication Services of Shreveport, Inc, Plaintiffs - Appellants, v Bellsouth Telecommunications Inc; the Louisiana Public Service Commission; Don Owen; Irma Muse Dixon; Dale Sittig; James M Field; Jack a Blossman also known as Jay Blossom; Commissioners of the Louisiana Public Service Commission, in their official capacities, Defendants - Appellees		United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit	United States	16 Jan 2001	WorldLII
Bell Atlantic Maryland, Inc v MCI Worldcom, Inc	240 F3d 279	United States Court of Appeals, Fourth Circuit	United States	14 Feb 2001	WorldLII	19
Bellsouth Telecommunications, Incorporated, Plaintiff-Appellee, United States of America; Federal Communications Commission, Intervenors, v North Carolina Utilities Commission, Defendant-Appellant, and US Lecof North Carolina, LLC, Defendant Bellsouth Telecommunications, Incorporated, Plaintiff-Appellee, United States of America; Federal Communications Commission, Intervenors, v North Carolina Utilities Commission, Defendant-Appellant, and Intermedia Communications, Defendant Bellsouth Telecommunications, Incorporated, Plaintiff-Appellee, v North Carolina Utilities Commission, Defendant-Appellant, McImetro Access Transmission Services, Incorporated, Defendant-Appellee, United States of America; Federal Communications Commission, Intervenors Bellsouth Telecommunications, Incorporated, Plaintiff-Appellee, United States of America; Federal Communications Commission, Intervenors, v US Lecof North Carolina, LLC, Defendant-Appellant, and North Carolina Utilities Commission, Defendant		United States Court of Appeals, Fourth Circuit	United States	14 Feb 2001	WorldLII
Cox v City of Dallas	256 F3d 281	United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit	United States	6 Aug 2001	WorldLII	10
Hurst v Texas Department of Assistive and Rehabilitative Services Dars	482 F3d 809	United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit	United States	26 Mar 2007	WorldLII
Islander East Pipeline Co Llc v Connecticut Department of Environmental Protection	482 F3d 79	United States Court of Appeals, Second Circuit	United States	5 Oct 2006	WorldLII
JOSEPH A , by next friend Corrine Wolfe; JOSEPHINE A , by next friend Corrine Wolfe; MICHAEL B , by next friend Lucy Gale McMurray; MICHELLE C , by next friend La Donna Harris and Lucy Gale McMurray; JOEL D , by next friend Lucy Gale McMurray; SUSAN E , by next friend Barbara Burns; DONALD E , by next friend Barbara Burns; Plaintiffs-Appellants, v LAWRENCE B INGRAM, MARGARET LARROGOITE, DAROLD CHRISTIANSEN, and JANET BRYAN, in their individual capacities, NORA BUCHANON, in her official capacity as County Office Manager of the Bernalillo County office of the Children Youth & Families Department, DEBORAH HARTZ, in her official capacity as Director of the Protective Services Division of the Children, Youth & Families Department, HEATHER WILSON, in her official capacity as secretary of the Children, Youth & Families Department, LINDA S GARCIA, in her official capacity as the County Office Manger of the Santa Fe County office of the Children, Youth & Families Department, Defendants-Appellees		United States Court of Appeals, Tenth Circuit	United States	7 Jan 2002	WorldLII
MCI Telecommunication Corporation v Bell Atlantic-Pennsylvania	271 F3d 491	United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit	United States	2 Nov 2001	WorldLII	25
Pace v Bogalusa City School Board	403 F3d 272	United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit	United States	16 Mar 2005	WorldLII	8
Verizon California Inc v R Peevey	413 F3d 1069	United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit	United States	6 Jul 2005	WorldLII	4

Legislation Cited

Legislation Name	Provision
Constitution
Eleventh Amendment
Fourteenth Amendment
Tenth Amendment
Constitution

Cases and Articles Cited

Case Name †	Citation(s)	Court	Jurisdiction	Date	Full Text	Citation Index
[1996] Act 5	[1996] Act 5		United Kingdom	circa 1996		11
[1996] Act 7	[1996] Act 7		United Kingdom	circa 1996		9
AT & T Corporation v Iowa Utils Bd	525 US 366; 142 L Ed 2d 835; 142 L Ed 2d 834; 119 SCt 721	United States Supreme Court	United States	25 Jan 1999	WorldLII	122
Chisholm v Georgia	2 US 419; 1 L Ed 440; 2 Dall 419	United States Supreme Court	United States	1 Feb 1793	WorldLII	154
Clark v Barnard	108 US 436; 27 L Ed 780; 2 SCt 878	United States Supreme Court	United States	7 May 1883	WorldLII	119
Cohens v Virginia	19 US 264; 6 Wheat 5; 6 Wheat 264; 5 L Ed 257	United States Supreme Court	United States	3 Mar 1821	WorldLII	381
College Savings Bank v Florida Prepaid Postsecondary Education Expense Board	527 US 666	United States Supreme Court	United States		Westlaw	114
Csx Transportation Incorporated	138 F3d 537	United States Court of Appeals, Fourth Circuit	United States	10 Mar 1998	WorldLII	10
David P Currie, Ex Parte Young After Seminole Tribe	72 New York University Law Review 547	New York University Law Review	United States		HeinOnline / LexisNexis	3
DENISE CHAVEZ,Plaintiff-Appellee, v ARTE PUBLICO PRESS, , Defendants-Appellants	204 F3d 601	United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit	United States	10 Mar 2000	WorldLII	3
Earles v State Bd of Certified Pub Accountants	139 F3d 1033	United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit	United States	3 Jun 1998	WorldLII	11
Edelman v Jordan	415 US 651; 94 SCt 1347; 97 SCt 1347; 39 L Ed 2d 662; 39 L Ed 662; 42 USLW 4419	United States Supreme Court	United States	13 May 1974	WorldLII	1028
Ex parte Young	209 US 166; 209 US 123; 13 LRANS 932; 14 Ann Cas 764; 52 L Ed 2d 714; 14 A & E Ann Cas 764; 52 L Ed 714; 13 LRANS 293; 28 SCt 441	United States Supreme Court	United States	23 Mar 1908	WorldLII	1057
Ex parte Young AT & T Communications of the South Central States, Inc v BellSouth Telecommunications, Inc	43 FSupp 2d 593		United States		Westlaw	2
FERC v Mississippi	456 US 742; 72 L Ed 2d 532; 102 SCt 2126	United States Supreme Court	United States	9 Sep 1982	WorldLII	93
Fernandes v Limmer	663 F2d 619		United States		Westlaw	31
Fitzpatrick v Bitzer	427 US 445; 49 L Ed 2d 614; 96 SCt 2666	United States Supreme Court	United States	28 Jun 1976	WorldLII	337
Franklin v Gwinnett County Public Schools	503 US 60; 117 L Ed 2d 208; 112 SCt 1028	United States Supreme Court	United States	26 Feb 1992	WorldLII	176
Great Northern Life Ins Co v Read	322 US 47; 88 L Ed 1121; 64 SCt 873; 88 L Ed 2d 1121	United States Supreme Court	United States	24 Apr 1944	WorldLII	135
GTE Fla , Inc v Johnson	964 FSupp 333		United States		Westlaw	2
GTE N Inc v Glazer	989 FSupp 922		United States		Westlaw	1
GTE Northwest, Inc v Nelson	969 FSupp 654		United States		Westlaw	1
GTE S Inc v Breathitt	963 FSupp 610		United States		Westlaw	1
GTE S Inc v Morrison	957 FSupp 800		United States		Westlaw	3
GTE Southwest, Inc v Graves	989 FSupp 1148		United States		Westlaw	1
Gunter v Atlantic Coast Line R Co	200 US 273; 50 L Ed 477; 26 SCt 252	United States Supreme Court	United States	15 Jan 1906	WorldLII	57
Hans v Louisiana	134 US 1; 134 US 15; 10 SCt 504; 33 L Ed 2d 842; 33 L Ed 842	United States Supreme Court	United States	3 Mar 1890	WorldLII	405
Hodel v Virginia Surface Mining & Reclamation Assn , Inc	452 US 264; 69 L Ed 2d 1; 101 SCt 2352	United States Supreme Court	United States	15 Jun 1981	WorldLII	278
Hudson v City of New Orleans	174 F3d 677	United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit	United States	13 May 1999	WorldLII	14
Idaho v Coeur d'Alene Tribe of Idaho	521 US 261; 138 L Ed 2d 438; 117 SCt 2028	United States Supreme Court	United States	23 Jun 1997	WorldLII	161
In re Ayers	123 US 451; 123 US 443; 31 L Ed 216; 8 SCt 164	United States Supreme Court	United States	5 Dec 1887	WorldLII	114
Iowa Utils Bd v FCC	120 F3d 753; 67 USLW 3153	United States Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit	United States	14 Oct 1997	WorldLII	45
Joseph Beers v Arkansas	61 US 527; 15 L Ed 991	United States Supreme Court	United States	1 Dec 1857	WorldLII	21
Kimel v Florida Bd of Regents	528 US 62; 145 L Ed 2d 522; 120 SCt 631	United States Supreme Court	United States	11 Jan 2000	WorldLII	175
MCI Telecomms Corporation v Ill Bell Tel Co	222 F3d 323	United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit	United States	24 Jul 2000	WorldLII	23
MCI Telecommunications Corporation v Pub Serv Comm'n of Utah			United States		Westlaw	9
Michigan Bell Tel Co v Climax Tel Co	202 F3d 862		United States		Westlaw	13
Missouri v Fiske	290 US 18; 78 L Ed 145; 54 SCt 18	United States Supreme Court	United States	6 Nov 1933	WorldLII	46
New York v United States	505 US 144; 120 L Ed 2d 120; 112 SCt 2408	United States Supreme Court	United States	19 Jun 1992	WorldLII	224
Parden v Terminal R Co	377 US 184; 12 L Ed 2d 233; 84 SCt 1207	United States Supreme Court	United States	22 Jun 1964	WorldLII	163
Pennhurst State School & Hospital v Halderman	465 US 89; 79 L Ed 2d 67; 104 SCt 900	United States Supreme Court	United States	23 Jan 1984	WorldLII	808
Pennsylvania v Union Gas Co	109 SCt 2273	United States Supreme Court	United States	15 Jun 1989	WorldLII	128
Petty v Tennessee-Missouri Bridge Comm'n	359 US 275; 79 SCt 785; 3 L Ed 804; 3 L Ed 2d 804; 74 SCt 785	United States Supreme Court	United States	20 Apr 1959	WorldLII	116
Printz v United States	521 US 898; 138 L Ed 2d 914; 117 SCt 2365	United States Supreme Court	United States	27 Jun 1997	WorldLII	176
Puerto Rico Aqueduct & Sewer Auth v Metcalf & Eddy, Inc	506 US 139; 121 L Ed 2d 605; 113 SCt 684	United States Supreme Court	United States	12 Jan 1993	WorldLII	256
Saldano v Texas	530 US 1212; 120 SCt 2214; 147 L Ed 2d 246	United States Supreme Court	United States	circa 1993	Westlaw	3
Schutten v Shell Oil Co	421 F2d 869	United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit	United States	30 Jan 1970	WorldLII	31
Seminole Tribe of Florida v Florida	517 US 44; 134 L Ed 2d 252; 116 SCt 1114	United States Supreme Court	United States	27 Mar 1996	WorldLII	459
South Dakota v Dole	483 US 203; 97 L Ed 2d 171; 107 SCt 2793	United States Supreme Court	United States	23 Jun 1987	WorldLII	122
Southwestern Bell Tel Co v Public Util Comm'n	208 F3d 475	United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit	United States	30 Mar 2000	WorldLII	26
Steward Machine Co v Davis	301 US 548; 81 L Ed 1279; 57 SCt 883	United States Supreme Court	United States	24 May 1937	WorldLII	157
Texas Office of Public Utility Counsel v FCC	183 F3d 393	United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit	United States	30 Jul 1999	WorldLII	19
United States v Texas Tech University	171 F3d 279; 15 IER Cases 6; 133 Ed Law Rep 691	United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit	United States	29 Mar 1999	WorldLII	31
Ysleta Del Sur Pueblo, Plaintiff-Appellee, v David Laney; Robert L Nichols; Anne S Wynne; Eddie Sanchez; and Rudy Lugo, Defendants-Appellants	199 F3d 281	United States Court of Appeals, Fifth Circuit	United States	13 Jan 2000	WorldLII	6
98 Idaho 99	98 Idaho 99		United States - Idaho	circa 2000		26
120 SCt 2007	120 SCt 2007		United States	circa 2007	Westlaw	1
121 SCt 54	121 SCt 54		United States	circa 2000	Westlaw	4
238 f3d 636			United States		Westlaw	10
530 US 1202	530 US 1202; 147 L Ed 2d 231; 120 SCt 2194	United States Supreme Court	United States		Westlaw	9

LawCite: Privacy | Disclaimers | Conditions of Use | Acknowledgements | Feedback