LawCite Search | LawCite Markup Tool | Help | Feedback

Law
Cite


Cases Referring to this Case | Law Reform Reports Referring to this Case | Law Journal Articles Referring to this Case | Legislation Cited | Cases and Articles Cited

Help

Oposa v Factoran   flag  39

224 SCRA 792
Philippine Supreme Court Reports Annotated
Supreme Court of the Philippines
Philippines

Cases Referring to this Case

Case Name †  Citation(s) Court Jurisdiction Date Full Text Citation Index
Alfredo Tano, Baldomero Tano, Danilo Tano, Romualdo Tano, Teocenes Midello, Angel De Mesa, Eulogio Tremocha, Felipe Ongonion, JR , Andres Linijan, Robert Lim, Virginia Lim, Felimon De Mesa, Generoso Aragon, Teodorico Andre, Romulo Del Rosario, Cholito Andre, Erick Montano, Andres Oliva, Vittorio Salvador, Leopoldo Aragon, Rafael Riba, Alejandro Leonila, Jose Damacinto, Ramiro Manaeg, Ruben Margate, Roberto Reyes, Danilo Pangarutan, Noe Golpan, Estanislao Romero, Nicanor Domingo, Roldan Tabang, Adriano Tabang, Freddie Sacamay, Miguel Trimocha, Pacencio Lababit, Pablo H Ompad, Celestino a Abano, Allan Almodai, Billy D Bartolay, Albino D Lique, Mechor J Layson, Melanie Amante, Claro E Yatoc, Mergeldo b Baldeo, Edgar M Almaseta, Joselito Manaeg, Liberato Andrada, JR , Roberto Berry, Ronald Villanueva, Eduardo Valmoria, Wilfredo Mendoza, Napoleon Babangga, Roberto Tadepa, Ruben Asingua, Silverio Gabo, Jerry Romero, David Panggarutan, Daniel Panggarutan, Romeo Agawin, Fernando Equiz, Dito Lequiz, Ronilo Moderable, Benedicto Torres, Rosito a Valdez, Cresencio a Sayang, Nicomedes S Acosta, Ereneo a Segarino, JR , Wilfredo a Rauto, Diosdado a Acosta, Bonifacio G Sismo, Tacio Aluba, Daniel b Baterzal, Eliseo Yba Ñ Ez, Diosdado E Hanchic, Eddie Escalicas, Eleazar b Baterzal, Dominador Halichic, Roosevelt Rismo-an, Robert C Mercader, Tirso Aresgado, Daniel Chavez, Danilo Chavez, Victor Villaroel, Ernesto C Yba Ñ Ez, Armando t Santillan, Rudy S Santillan, Jodjen Ilustrisimo, Nestor Salangron, Alberto Salangron, Roger l Roxas, Francisco t Anticano, Pastor Salangron, Bienvenido Santillan, Gilbuena Laddy, Fidel Benjamin, Jovelito Belgano, Honey Pariol, Antonio Salangron, Nicasio Salangron, and Airline Shippers Association of Palawan v Hon Gov Salvador P Socrates, Members of Sangguniang Panlalawigan of Palawan, namely, Vice-Governor Joel t Reyes, Jose D Zabala, Rosalino R Acosta, Joselito a Cadlaon, Andres R Baaco, Nelson P Peneyra, Cipriano C Barroma, Claro E Ordinario, Ernesto a l Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 21 Aug 1997 AsianLII flag
Alfredo Tano, Baldomero Tano, Danilo Tano, Romualdo Tano, Teocenes Midello, Angel De Mesa, Eulogio Tremocha, Felipe Ongonion, JR , Andres Linijan, Robert Lim, Virginia Lim, Felimon De Mesa, Generoso Aragon, Teodorico Andre, Romulo Del Rosario, Cholito Andre, Erick Montano, Andres Oliva, Vittorio Salvador, Leopoldo Aragon, Rafael Riba, Alejandro Leonila, Jose Damacinto, Ramiro Manaeg, Ruben Margate, Roberto Reyes, Danilo Pangarutan, Noe Golpan, Estanislao Romero, Nicanor Domingo, Roldan Tabang, Adriano Tabang, Freddie Sacamay, Miguel Trimocha, Pacencio Lababit, Pablo H Ompad, Celestino a Abano, Allan Almodai, Billy D Bartolay, Albino D Lique, Mechor J Layson, Melanie Amante, Claro E Yatoc, Mergeldo b Baldeo, Edgar M Almaseta, Joselito Manaeg, Liberato Andrada, JR , Roberto Berry, Ronald Villanueva, Eduardo Valmoria, Wilfredo Mendoza, Napoleon Babangga, Roberto Tadepa, Ruben Asingua, Silverio Gabo, Jerry Romero, David Panggarutan, Daniel Panggarutan, Romeo Agawin, Fernando Equiz, Dito Lequiz, Ronilo Moderable, Benedicto Torres, Rosito a Valdez, Cresencio a Sayang, Nicomedes S Acosta, Ereneo a Segarino, JR , Wilfredo a Rauto, Diosdado a Acosta, Bonifacio G Sismo, Tacio Aluba, Daniel b Baterzal, Eliseo Yba Ñ Ez, Diosdado E Hanchic, Eddie Escalicas, Eleazar b Baterzal, Dominador Halichic, Roosevelt Rismo-an, Robert C Mercader, Tirso Aresgado, Daniel Chavez, Danilo Chavez, Victor Villaroel, Ernesto C Yba Ñ Ez, Armando t Santillan, Rudy S Santillan, Jodjen Ilustrisimo, Nestor Salangron, Alberto Salangron, Roger l Roxas, Francisco t Anticano, Pastor Salangron, Bienvenido Santillan, Gilbuena Laddy, Fidel Benjamin, Jovelito Belgano, Honey Pariol, Antonio Salangron, Nicasio Salangron, and Airline Shippers Association of Palawan v Hon Gov Salvador P Socrates, Members of Sangguniang Panlalawigan of Palawan, namely, Vice-Governor Joel t Reyes, Jose D Zabala, Rosalino R Acosta, Joselito a Cadlaon, Andres R Baaco, Nelson P Peneyra, Cipriano C Barroma, Claro E Ordinario, Ernesto a l Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 21 Aug 1997 AsianLII flag
Arturo M Tolentino v the Secretary of Finance and the Commissioner of Internal Revenue [1994] PHSC 498 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 25 Aug 1994 AsianLII flag
Bangus Fry Fisherfolk, Diwata Magbuhos, Angelita Binay, Elma Garcia, Virgilio Panguio, Arsenio Castillo, Ariel Panguio, Antonio Panguio, Antonio Bunquin, Generoso Bunquin, Charlie Dimayacyac, Renato Panguio, Atilano Bunquin, Carlos Chavez, Juan Dimayacyac, Filemon Bunquin, Mario Magbuhos, Mauro Magbuhos, Nora Magbuhos, Jeovilyn, Genalyn and Jorvan Quimuel, minors, represented by their parents Feliciana and Sabino Quimuel, Maricar Magbuhos, minor, represented by her parents Carmelita and Antonio Magbuhos, Marlo Binay, minor, represented by his parents Efrenita and Charlito Binay, and the Bangus, Bangus Fry and other Marine Life of Minolo Cove v the Honorable Enrico Lanzanas as Judge of the Regional Trial Court of Manila, Branch Vii, the Department of Environment and Natural Resources — Region IV, represented by its Regional Executive Director and its Regional Director for Environment, the National Power Corporation, Oriental Mindoro Electric Cooperative, Provincial Government of Oriental Mindoro, herein represented by Governor Rodolfo Valencia, Puerto Galera Mayor Gregorio Delgado, Vice Mayor Aristeo Atienza, and Members of the Sangguniang Bayan of Puerto Galera, Juan Ascan, JR , Rafael Romey, Cenon Salcedo, Jerry Dalisay, Simon Balitaan, Renato Cataquis, Marcelino Banaag, Daniel Enriquez, Amelyn Marco, Gabriel Ilagan, Municipal Engineer Rodel Rubio, and Municipal Planning and Development Coordinator Wilhelmina Lineses [2003] PHSC 399 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 10 Jul 2003 AsianLII flag
Bangus Fry Fisherfolk, Diwata Magbuhos, Angelita Binay, Elma Garcia, Virgilio Panguio, Arsenio Castillo, Ariel Panguio, Antonio Panguio, Antonio Bunquin, Generoso Bunquin, Charlie Dimayacyac, Renato Panguio, Atilano Bunquin, Carlos Chavez, Juan Dimayacyac, Filemon Bunquin, Mario Magbuhos, Mauro Magbuhos, Nora Magbuhos, Jeovilyn, Genalyn and Jorvan Quimuel, minors, represented by their parents Feliciana and Sabino Quimuel, Maricar Magbuhos, minor, represented by her parents Carmelita and Antonio Magbuhos, Marlo Binay, minor, represented by his parents Efrenita and Charlito Binay, and the Bangus, Bangus Fry and other Marine Life of Minolo Cove v the Honorable Enrico Lanzanas as Judge of the Regional Trial Court of Manila, Branch Vii, the Department of Environment and Natural Resources — Region IV, represented by its Regional Executive Director and its Regional Director for Environment, the National Power Corporation, Oriental Mindoro Electric Cooperative, Provincial Government of Oriental Mindoro, herein represented by Governor Rodolfo Valencia, Puerto Galera Mayor Gregorio Delgado, Vice Mayor Aristeo Atienza, and Members of the Sangguniang Bayan of Puerto Galera, Juan Ascan, JR , Rafael Romey, Cenon Salcedo, Jerry Dalisay, Simon Balitaan, Renato Cataquis, Marcelino Banaag, Daniel Enriquez, Amelyn Marco, Gabriel Ilagan, Municipal Engineer Rodel Rubio, and Municipal Planning and Development Coordinator Wilhelmina Lineses - GR Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 10 Jul 2003 AsianLII flag
Board of Optometry, represented by its Chairman, DR Primitiva Y Perez-Sison, Professional Regulation Commission, represented by its Commissioner, Hermogenes P Pobre, Department of Health, represented by its Secretary, DR Hilarion M Ramiro, Bureau of Foods and Drugs, represented by its Director, DR Quintin l Kintanar, Department of Budget and Management, represented by its Secretary, Salvador M Enriquez, JR , and Bureau of Higher Education, represented by its Director, Mona D Valisno v Hon Angel b Colet, Presiding Judge, Regional Trial Court of Manila, Branch 29, Acebedo Optical Co, Inc , represented by its President and Chairman of the Board, Miguel P Acebedo, Optometry Practitioners Association of the Philippines (Opap), represented by its President, DR Miriam f Llave, Cenevis Optometrist Association (Coa), represented by its President, DR Roberto Rodis, JR , Association of Christian-Muslim Optometrist (Acmo), represented by its President, DR Cyril Corales, Southern Mindanao Optometrist Association of the Phils , Inc (Smoap), represented by its President, DR Elmer Villarosa, and Republica a Panol Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 30 Jul 1996 AsianLII flag
Dolmar Property Ventures, Inc , v Hon Fatima Gonzales Asdala, [2005] PHCA 670 Court of Appeals of the Philippines Philippines 31 Jan 2005 AsianLII flag
Ernesto b Francisco, JR Nagmamalasakit NA Mga Manananggol NG Mga Manggagawang Pilipino, Inc , Its Officers and Members, petitioner-in-intervention, World War II Veterans Legionaries of the Philippines, Inc , petitioner-in-intervention, v the House of Representatives, Represented by Speaker Jose G De Venecia, the Senate, Represented by Senate President Franklin M Drilon, Representative Gilberto C Teodoro, JR and Representative Felix William b Fuentebella Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 10 Nov 2003 AsianLII flag
Ernesto b Francisco, JR Nagmamalasakit NA Mga Manananggol NG Mga Manggagawang Pilipino, Inc , Its Officers and Members, petitioner-in-intervention, World War II Veterans Legionaries of the Philippines, Inc , petitioner-in-intervention, v the House of Representatives, Represented by Speaker Jose G De Venecia, the Senate, Represented by Senate President Franklin M Drilon, Representative Gilberto C Teodoro, JR and Representative Felix William b Fuentebella - GR Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 10 Nov 2003 AsianLII flag
Francisco I Chavez v Hon Alberto G Romulo, [2004] PHSC 613 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 9 Jun 2004 AsianLII flag
Francisco i Chavez v Presidential Commission on Good Government (PCGG) and Magtanggol Gunigundo (in his capacity as chairman of the PCGG) Gloria a Jopson, Celnan a Jopson, Scarlet a Jopson, and Teresa a Jopson, petitioners-in-intervention [1998] PHSC 762 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 9 Dec 1998 AsianLII flag
Goldwell Properties v Sps Manuel Tan [2004] PHCA 2376 Court of Appeals of the Philippines Philippines 8 Dec 2004 AsianLII flag
Heherson Alvarez v Picop Resources, Inc / Picop Resources, Inc Vs Heherson Alvarez / Angelo T Reyes Vs Paper Industries Corporation of the Philippines (PICOP) [2006] PHSC 1373 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 29 Nov 2006 AsianLII flag
Heirs of Atty Jose C Reyes, v RP [2006] PHSC 797 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 3 Aug 2006 AsianLII flag
Hilarion M Henares, Jr v Land Transportation Franchising and Regulatory Board [2006] PHSC 1233 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 23 Oct 2006 AsianLII flag
Hon Heherson T Alvarez v PICOP Resources, Inc /PICOP Resources, Inc Vs Hon Heherson T Alavarez/Hon Angelo T Reyes Vs Paper Industries Corporation of the Philippines (PICOP) [2009] PHSC 1236 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 3 Dec 2009 AsianLII flag
Kilosbayan, Incorporated, Jovito R Salonga, Cirilo a Rigos, Erme Camba, Emilio C Capulong, JR , Jose t Apolo, Ephraim Tendero, Fernando Santiago, Jose Abcede, Christine Tan, Rafael G Fernando, Raoul v Victorino, Jose Cunanan, Quintin S Doromal, Sen Freddie Webb, Sen Wigberto TA Ñ Ada, Rep Joker P Arroyo v Manuel l Morato, in his capacity as Chairman of the Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office, and the Philippine Gaming Management Corporation Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 16 Nov 1995 AsianLII flag
Metropolitan Manila Development Authority v Dante O Garin [2005] PHSC 415 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 15 Apr 2005 AsianLII flag
MMDA v Residents of Manila Bay [2008] PHSC 1349 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 18 Dec 2008 AsianLII flag
Nicasio I Alcantara v Dept of Environment & Natural Resources, [2008] PHSC 795 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 31 Jul 2008 AsianLII flag
Picop Resources, Inc v Base Metals Mineral Resources Corporation, [2006] PHSC 1164 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 6 Dec 2006 AsianLII flag
Prof Merlin M Magallona, v Eduardo Ermita, [2011] PHSC 653 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 16 Aug 2011 AsianLII flag
Province of Rizal, v Executive Secretary, [2005] PHSC 1363 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 13 Dec 2005 AsianLII flag
Republic of the Phil, etc , v Hon Ramon S Caguioa, etc , [2007] PHSC 1195 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 15 Oct 2007 AsianLII flag
Republic of the Philippines etc v Pagadian City Timber Co Inc [2008] PHSC 975 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 16 Sep 2008 AsianLII flag
Republic of the Philippines, v Rosemoor Mining and Development Corporation, [2004] PHSC 361 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 30 Mar 2004 AsianLII flag
Rev Ely Velez Pamatong v Commission on Elections [2004] PHSC 379 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 13 Apr 2004 AsianLII flag
Sen Miriam Defensor Santiago and Sen Francisco S Tatad v Sen Teofisto t Guingona, JR and Sen Marcelo b Fernan [1998] PHSC 713 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 18 Nov 1998 AsianLII flag
Senator Aquilino Pimentel, Jr , v Office of the Executive Secretary, [2005] PHSC 706 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 6 Jul 2005 AsianLII flag
Southeast Mindanao Gold Mining Corporation v Balite Portal Mining Cooperative similarly situated; and the Honorable Antonio Cerilles, in his capacity as Secretary of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (Denr), Provincial Mining Regulatory Board of Davao (PMRB-Davao) [2002] PHSC 217 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 3 Apr 2002 AsianLII flag
Sta Ines Melale Forest Products Corporation v Hon Catalino MacAraig, JR , Executive Secretary, Office of the President; Hon Samilo N Barlongay, Acting Deputy Executive Secretary, Office of the President; Hon Secretary of Natural Resources; Hon Director of Bureau of Forest Development; Agusan Wood Industries, Inc and Kalilid Wood Industries, Inc [1998] PHSC 747 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 2 Dec 1998 AsianLII flag
United BF Homeowners' Asso , Inc , v The City Mayor of Paranaque City, [2007] PHSC 142 Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 7 Feb 2007 AsianLII flag
Wigberto E TA Ñ Ada and Anna Dominique Coseteng, as members of the Philippine Senate and as taxpayers; Gregorio Andolana and Joker Arroyo as members of the House of Representatives and as taxpayers; Nicanor P Perlas and Horacio R Morales, both as taxpayers; Civil Liberties Union, National Economic Protectionism Association, Center for Alternative Development Initiatives, Likas-Kayang Kaunlaran Foundation, Inc , Philippine Rural Reconstruction Movement, Demokratikong Kilusan NG Magbubukid NG Pilipinas, Inc , and Philippine Peasant Institute, in representation of various taxpayers and as non-governmental organizations v Edgardo Angara, Alberto Romulo, Leticia Ramos-Shahani, Heherson Alvarez, Agapito Aquino, Rodolfo Biazon, Neptali Gonzales, Ernesto Herrera, Jose Lina, Gloria MacApagal-Arroyo, Orlando Mercado, Blas Ople, John Osme Ñ a, Santanina Rasul, Ramon Revilla, Raul Roco, Francisco Tatad and Freddie Webb, in their respective capacities as members of the Philippine Senate who concurred in the ratification by the President of the Philippines of the Agreement Establishing the World Trade Organization; Salvador Enriquez, in his capacity as Secretary of Budget and Management; Caridad Valdehuesa, in her capacity as National Treasurer; Rizalino Navarro, in his capacity as Secretary of Trade and Industry; Roberto Sebastian, in his capacity as Secretary of Agriculture; Roberto De Ocampo, in his capacity as Secretary of Finance; Roberto Romulo, in his capacity as Secretary of Foreign Affairs; and Teofisto t Guingona, in his capacity as Executive Secretary - GR Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 2 May 1997 AsianLII flag
Wigberto E TA Ñ Ada and Anna Dominique Coseteng, as members of the Philippine Senate and as taxpayers; Gregorio Andolana and Joker Arroyo as members of the House of Representatives and as taxpayers; Nicanor P Perlas and Horacio R Morales, both as taxpayers; Civil Liberties Union, National Economic Protectionism Association, Center for Alternative Development Initiatives, Likas-Kayang Kaunlaran Foundation, Inc , Philippine Rural Reconstruction Movement, Demokratikong Kilusan NG Magbubukid NG Pilipinas, Inc , and Philippine Peasant Institute, in representation of various taxpayers and as non-governmental organizations v Edgardo Angara, Alberto Romulo, Leticia Ramos-Shahani, Heherson Alvarez, Agapito Aquino, Rodolfo Biazon, Neptali Gonzales, Ernesto Herrera, Jose Lina, Gloria MacApagal-Arroyo, Orlando Mercado, Blas Ople, John Osme Ñ a, Santanina Rasul, Ramon Revilla, Raul Roco, Francisco Tatad and Freddie Webb, in their respective capacities as members of the Philippine Senate who concurred in the ratification by the President of the Philippines of the Agreement Establishing the World Trade Organization; Salvador Enriquez, in his capacity as Secretary of Budget and Management; Caridad Valdehuesa, in her capacity as National Treasurer; Rizalino Navarro, in his capacity as Secretary of Trade and Industry; Roberto Sebastian, in his capacity as Secretary of Agriculture; Roberto De Ocampo, in his capacity as Secretary of Finance; Roberto Romulo, in his capacity as Secretary of Foreign Affairs; and Teofisto t Guingona, in his capacity as Executive Secretary Supreme Court of the Philippines Philippines 2 May 1997 AsianLII flag

Law Journal Articles Referring to this Case

Journal Article Title †  Citation(s) Author Jurisdiction Date Full Text Citation Index
"New Zealand: Country Report on Human Rights" [2009] VUWLawRw 6 Baird, Natalie; Glazebrook, Susan; Holden, Sasha New Zealand circa 2009 NZLII flag
"Isagani A Cruz and Cesar S Europa v Secretary of Environment and Natural Resources, Secretary of Budget and Management, and the Chair and Commission of the National Commission on Indigenous Peoples - Case Summary" (2002) 7 (4) Australian Indigenous Law Reporter 42 Editors Australia circa 2002 AustLII flag
"Philippines Regional Court Reiterates Constitutional Right to Environment: The Manila Bay case" [2002] AsPacJlEnvLaw 11 (2002) 7 (3-4) Asia Pacific Journal of Environmental Law 1 Lyster, Rosemary Australia circa 2002 AustLII flag
"Old Solutions to New Problems: Providing for Intergenerational Equity in National Institutions" (2010) 14 New Zealand Journal of Environmental Law 25 Sacha Hollis New Zealand circa 2010 NZLII flag 1
"Of Centenaries and Centennials: A Filipino Contribution to the Australian Debate on A Bill of Rights" (2000) 6 Australian Journal of Human Rights 151 Santos Jr, Soliman M Australia circa 2000 AustLII flag

LawCite: Privacy | Disclaimers | Conditions of Use | Acknowledgements | Feedback